What are your thoughts on swanndri gear, is it worth the money?

  • Come along to the amazing Summer Moot (21st July - 2nd August), a festival of bushcrafting and camping in a beautiful woodland PLEASE CLICK HERE for more information.
In a word no. Don't get me wrong they are good but for the money you can get better or just as good for less. The are hard wearing but about as windproof as a tea bag.

To behonest I wear an old Herdwick wool jumper of a Korean War GI wool field shirt more often than not in Autunm. The field shirt is better as it is half way betwee a shirt and coat, button all the way and is much more windproof.

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1953-KOREAN-W...NameZWD2VQQcmdZViewItemQQ_trksidZp1638Q2em122

Luckily I got mine cheap.
 
Got a new one today, but it doesnt seem as good a quality as the old one i have, i also have a bison shirt which is better quality.
 
Why not get one of the Bison Buscraft shirts that are made in the UK?

You'll find some pretty good write-ups here.

Cheers

Mike

Or 5 of these


http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Dockers-Ameri...VQQcmdZViewItemQQ_trksidZp1638Q2em118Q2el1247

Not as good, but still good, the seller will take an offer, and they work well, toasty warm. I have a swanni, but they are a bit overpriced to say the least, and if anyone member spends over £40 on a shirt, please give me a PM as I sell insurence and investment bonds part time and you sound like my kind of person to give a quick sales pitch to and earn a few quid;)
 
I've had a Swannie Ranger for over 15 years and love it.
It's still going strong and I'd buy another (not that I think I will ever need to).
How many people have (nearly) 16 year old shirts still in use.
It's even older than the kids.
(oh, and it also say's Swanndri on it:cool: :rolleyes: :D :D )
 
Had mine two years and wear it all winter as a mid layer, spring as an outer with a wind stopping layer bellow and in summer as an outer in the evening. Wear it round the fire and has never caught a spark and when worn to the pub and folk in the pub ask you about bushcraft...; )
jon
 
I've been extremely pleased with my Mosgiel. If anything, I find them a bit too warm sometimes but they are robust and water resistant.

A massive improvement however would be to dispense with the floppy shirt collar, of a size more appropriate to the “Life On Mars” wardrobe department, and extend the zip through to the top of a high collar as per my Andy Rouse Paramo Mountain Vent Pull-On. That really would improve its value as a wind-blocker by a huge degree.

I know what you're getting at but I quite like the high collar (which is probably why it's floppy) as it keeps your neck warm. I agree that the zip should extend all the way up, as there's an annoying gap at the top of the zip where cold air can get in but I reckon it might be a bit tight? In fact, they have some very odd sizing in the neck/hood area: it is almost impossible to close the buttoned flap at the base of the hood unless you have a pencil neck. I'm thinking of making an extension piece but I'm guessing it will spoil the look of the garment.

Overall, a really nice coat (come on, people: it's not a shirt!) but I do wonder about some of the design issues around the neck area: surely, after so long, they would have solved these issues?
 
I bought my Swannie while in New Zealand and have given it heaps of abuse over the years. It's still hanging on in there.

That said, I've also got one of the Bison Bushcraft shirts. It's U.K. made and I think superior in almost every way.

If you're going to the southern hemisphere at any stage soon, buy a Swannie; if you're not, I'd get hold of the Bison version.

As ever, I've no connection with Bison - I'm just a happy customer.:)
 
Finally got round to listing my shirt on ebay UK item number 260244300444 , see earlier post about my unexpected wool allergy.
 
Personal discovery of Swanndri clothing was made by myself approximately four years ago. I was out in New Zealand and popped into their store in Rickerton on the edge of Christchurch. I noted that most of their products were assembled in China and at that time as a consequence their products of that period, when compared to the original NZ made products, did suffer quality control as a result. However, I noticed a sale rack and bought two items in the form of a Merino Vest and a Bush Shirt which were old NZ stock. I have worn both for years and without washing. The latter statement is not a declaration of any form of personal unhygienic issues on my part, the Swanni's simply do not suffer from odour issues like most other fabrics (the other natural material being silk).

I sold off the Bushshirt and regretted it after a few months. The Merino wool not only evades odour issues, but it resistant to fire sparks, so ideal to sitting around a camp fire. Man made fleece on the other hand will suffer bobbling, and will melt if so much as a cinder floats by the stuff. Merino wool will also serve to maintain and regulate body temperature far better than fleece and other man made fabrics, it will also keep your body warm when wet, so you are less likely to suffer chills and hypothermia.

I still have my sleeveless Swanni Gilli and always look forward to a drop in temperature so I can don it.

It is now August 2011 and I have just returned from my second visit to NZ. I again visited the Swanndri shop in CC, this time I noted it has changed it's presentation and marketing style of the goods, they seem to have an aim on the fashion and trendy market. However the traditional Swanni's are still available. The other sources for Swanni's are charity shops and used clothing warehouses and you will discover these to be in abundance in NZ.

I managed to find a Merino Wool Shirt for $5 (£2.50) and Rakaia Jacket for a mere $2 (£1). My travel companion found quite a few Swanndri Shirts and other jackets in such shops which still had labels in place for similar amounts of money.

My own preference is for original NZ made Swanni's as they are built much better quality and seem to last for generations. The latter made Chinese varieties are still OK and as such I would recommend them, but the quality of such items is obvious when you perform direct comparisons between one made in NZ and one from China.

It is also worth keeping an eye on Ebay and also visiting Game Fairs in the UK. I have found non branded Swanndri items at these events, often at knock down prices.

As for me, I cannot wait for winter to come so I can wear my Swannri's.

Be well.

Shamanpan (Pete)
 
Personal discovery of Swanndri clothing was made by myself approximately four years ago. I was out in New Zealand and popped into their store in Rickerton on the edge of Christchurch. I noted that most of their products were assembled in China and at that time as a consequence their products of that period, when compared to the original NZ made products, did suffer quality control as a result. However, I noticed a sale rack and bought two items in the form of a Merino Vest and a Bush Shirt which were old NZ stock. I have worn both for years and without washing. The latter statement is not a declaration of any form of personal unhygienic issues on my part, the Swanni's simply do not suffer from odour issues like most other fabrics (the other natural material being silk).

I sold off the Bushshirt and regretted it after a few months. The Merino wool not only evades odour issues, but it resistant to fire sparks, so ideal to sitting around a camp fire. Man made fleece on the other hand will suffer bobbling, and will melt if so much as a cinder floats by the stuff. Merino wool will also serve to maintain and regulate body temperature far better than fleece and other man made fabrics, it will also keep your body warm when wet, so you are less likely to suffer chills and hypothermia.

I still have my sleeveless Swanni Gilli and always look forward to a drop in temperature so I can don it.

It is now August 2011 and I have just returned from my second visit to NZ. I again visited the Swanndri shop in CC, this time I noted it has changed it's presentation and marketing style of the goods, they seem to have an aim on the fashion and trendy market. However the traditional Swanni's are still available. The other sources for Swanni's are charity shops and used clothing warehouses and you will discover these to be in abundance in NZ.

I managed to find a Merino Wool Shirt for $5 (£2.50) and Rakaia Jacket for a mere $2 (£1). My travel companion found quite a few Swanndri Shirts and other jackets in such shops which still had labels in place for similar amounts of money.

My own preference is for original NZ made Swanni's as they are built much better quality and seem to last for generations. The latter made Chinese varieties are still OK and as such I would recommend them, but the quality of such items is obvious when you perform direct comparisons between one made in NZ and one from China.

It is also worth keeping an eye on Ebay and also visiting Game Fairs in the UK. I have found non branded Swanndri items at these events, often at knock down prices.

As for me, I cannot wait for winter to come so I can wear my Swannri's.

Be well.

Shamanpan (Pete)
 
I have a Ranger shirt in the green and brown plaid, I like it ok but I would not pay full price for one. I got mine from a US discounter for about $30US and to me that is about all it is worth. I can get a new USMC wool sweater for $31 and I have several old US Army wool sweaters with the 5 button neck and I prefer either sweather to the Swanni. The sizing is odd too. A good heavy wool shirt is the Woolrich Alaskan shirt. I have had one for 30 years and only lost one button. Well made for sure!
 
For those perusing this old thread and considering the purchase of a Swannie Ranger shirt, you should also have a look at the 'Bison Bushcraft Guide Shirt'.

The Bison shirt is a much better product, albeit more prone to shrinkage if not washed properly, take that into consideration when choosing a size and you will get years of use from it.

The Swanndri hooded bush shirt remains one of my favorite outdoor garments.

swannie.jpg


:)
 
Last edited:

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE