Far better than wellies (although I use Grubbs Stalkers with vibram soles), warmer, much better to walk long distances in. They aren't waders for sure but for general muck shovelling, I love mine. I have nearly worn my first pair out now...but thats several years hard use
Just remembered a funny tale -My mate had just bought a pair of real tree boots whilst camping in the lakes -he got talking to a one legged fisherman this day whilst at the camp site -The next day when he woke up ,the fisherman had left the camp and so had one of his boots !!!!!!