I'll go with the poncho most of the year. Winter, I used a BD megamid (floorless shelter). You cant cheat with winter in new england...it gets COLD!!!!
w00dsmoke said:For many years I used two German army poncho's then a Uk one studded onto a 58 bag then a bivi sheet/bag and now a TIPI after many tents.
Why?
In my opinion only a fool would use a poncho tarp combo in some of the high windier wilder parts of scotland in winter (I know because I was that poor fool for many years!)
Tent / bivi sheet for some of the year is okay but a guy needs to be mossie free when changing cooking etc
Tent is great fulfills many needs warmth, shelter, space etc
But hey a TIPI and you have all the benefits of a tarp with the protection of a tent!
Jon Pickett said:Hmmmmm, landrover is not on the list...Just boarded out the roof rack to take a tent and am boarding out the inside to create a sleeping, cooking area....
gunnix said:Can't imagine how you'd carry a tipi in your backpack though
Nathan Sturgess said:I prefer natural shelter but i voted Tarp because it is more practical and quicker to set up than a natural shelter