a quick experiment
- Thread starter catweasel
- Start date
-
Hey Guest, Early bird pricing on the Summer Moot (29th July - 10th August) available until April 6th, we'd love you to come. PLEASE CLICK HERE to early bird price and get more information.
It's a very good knife made by a craftsman to be bombproof and fit for it's intended purpose. And it is. It's one of the best made knives I've ever held. Personally I don't need the serrations, but I understand why they are there and why they are designed like that. Quality.
Sorry - it looks awful in my eyes!
The handle looks very "tactical" (I prefer wood...) and also uncomfortable, the blade looks too wide for a lot of carving tasks and I am not at all keen on serrations, especially on fixed blade knives and even more so in that position where I want to get max power for deep clean cuts ...not for me I am afraid - though it looks pretty strong (what steel and thickness is the steel) and well built. The leatherwork looks good...but I am not a big fan of horizontal carries....
Sorry - but you did ask...
The handle looks very "tactical" (I prefer wood...) and also uncomfortable, the blade looks too wide for a lot of carving tasks and I am not at all keen on serrations, especially on fixed blade knives and even more so in that position where I want to get max power for deep clean cuts ...not for me I am afraid - though it looks pretty strong (what steel and thickness is the steel) and well built. The leatherwork looks good...but I am not a big fan of horizontal carries....
Sorry - but you did ask...
i think its pretty nasty if im honist. i don't like the flat sides of the handle, it reminds me of a kitchen knife and serated edges are useless in my book.
what is the funny cut out in the handle all about???
pete
what is the funny cut out in the handle all about???
pete
My reply went in before I realised the BG connection...my comments still stand though!
The handles are surprisingly comfortable and one of the most ergonomic knives I've used, the cut out just follows the natural lie of the fingers. It's one of those knives like Spyderco, you need to hold it to see why it works, visuals alone just don't do the things justice. The serrations were designed and made to be sharpened on pebbles in an emergenct situation. It is primarily a survival knife and is quite good in that aspect, for more real practical use, I'd go for the plain edge version. The Raven series is better for us shrafters, but that is a quality bit of kit.
Rob Bayley has recently cut any endorsement by BG.
Rob Bayley has recently cut any endorsement by BG.
Last edited:
i know you were just commenting on the knife John, i don't like the serations either, i do however like the knife with the plain edge. Strong bullet proof tool that does exactly what it says on the tin.
pete_t.....no it's not mate, check out the signature on the second picture and catweasels comments !
infact, it's not about the knife at all !
infact, it's not about the knife at all !
Personally i prefer a more traditional blade like a scandi or a nice drop point with wooden clothes.As for the knife pictured it looks like a technically precise piece of craftsmanship built for the job.Not my cup of tea but like to see one for real.
and this is the same kinfe
i reckon he spoils anything he is associated with shame really
not Bear bashing ?.........really !!
http://www.bayleyknife.com/site/index.aspx
Rob made the knife for BG, and you've seen the way he treats his knives. It's a solid testament to the solidity of the construction. Rob even machines the bolts himself.
This is my favourite:
Last edited:
Maybe you should have a look on BB, loads of owners and users on there. You'll find more people who know of the knife due to the maker and not the user.
