Anyone saw Dave Canterbury on youtube stich his own hand, anyone ever did this,what is a medic saying about this and has it anything to do with self aid ?.
self stitching your wound
- Thread starter ghillieman
- Start date
-
Hey Guest, Early bird pricing on the Summer Moot (29th July - 10th August) available until April 6th, we'd love you to come. PLEASE CLICK HERE to early bird price and get more information.
Pretty much everything tht needs to be said has been said here: http://www.bushcraftusa.com/forum/showthread.php?t=6411&
would not do it my self, never would use superglue also, i saw the comments on american bushcraft, but then again i am interested in a different point of view
Koa on BCUSA said:
How many non-medical people, without recourse to Google and Thickipedia, even know what half those things are let alone how to avoid damaging them while stitching themselves back together? Not many, I daresay, certainly not I.
If you cut yourself in the field badly enough to actually require stitching to save your life, chances are very good indeed that you're not going to be in good enough shape to actually do the stitching yourself. Little cuts are different as in Dave's video. If you notice, Dave doesn't look his usual bouncy self and that's a pretty minor cut in the 'life threatening stakes'.
He'd apparently cut himself to the bone, about an hour previously, across a knuckle. It had already stopped bleeding by the looks of things, why stitch it at all? Gauze and tape, perhaps a few steri-strips underneath to keep it tight, walk out the way you came in and go straight to casualty where they'll get around to you after they finish sewing the drunks back together.
Best bet - don't fail to practice good knife safety.
first aid methods that i favor most is the things i learned in the service, followed several civilan first aid courses afterwards, but the basic and simple things works best for my point of view.
I followed Dave Canterburys efforts on the tube, and untill this item ,i tought he was a pretty serious guy , i seldom take a look anymore.
I followed Dave Canterburys efforts on the tube, and untill this item ,i tought he was a pretty serious guy , i seldom take a look anymore.
Various branches of the homo genus seem to have survived for millions of years before the invention of the needle, let alone suturing. However did we manage that?
I do know of a GP who performed his own vasectomy, with the aid of a mirror. I reckon he earned the £80 minor surgery fee for that.
You really need to check for neurovascular or tendon injury before suturing anything, and you certainly do not want to close a contaminated wound. I close a lot of minor wounds either with sutures, tissue adhesive or steristrips. Sutures are most useful for scalp wounds, which bleed like stink until you close them.
Incised wounds that go deeper than the subcut fat should be treated with great caution. Injury to underlying structures needs to be excluded, and that sometimes means examination in theatre.
You really need to check for neurovascular or tendon injury before suturing anything, and you certainly do not want to close a contaminated wound. I close a lot of minor wounds either with sutures, tissue adhesive or steristrips. Sutures are most useful for scalp wounds, which bleed like stink until you close them.
Incised wounds that go deeper than the subcut fat should be treated with great caution. Injury to underlying structures needs to be excluded, and that sometimes means examination in theatre.
Hmmm...... 
Steri-strips, pad and tape for me please. Worked for me and patients i've treated well in the past
I've been taught suturing, but would never dream of hands or face (too complex). The vast majority of wounds don't need suturing. Also deep wounds need specialist techniques to suture (usually sutured layer by layer) to ensure that no cavity is left (unless a surgical drain is placed) otherwise the resulting infection is not pretty.
Dermabond/tissue adhesives are fine, but are only useful on superficial wounds and where no tendon/nerve damage has occured, unless these have been dealt with seperately and you are using the glue to provide a low scarring 'cosmetic' closure
Steri-strips, pad and tape for me please. Worked for me and patients i've treated well in the past
I've been taught suturing, but would never dream of hands or face (too complex). The vast majority of wounds don't need suturing. Also deep wounds need specialist techniques to suture (usually sutured layer by layer) to ensure that no cavity is left (unless a surgical drain is placed) otherwise the resulting infection is not pretty.
Dermabond/tissue adhesives are fine, but are only useful on superficial wounds and where no tendon/nerve damage has occured, unless these have been dealt with seperately and you are using the glue to provide a low scarring 'cosmetic' closure
all i have with me most of time is a field dressing a little bottle of iodine and small tweezers, never let me down yet.
rancid badger
Bushcrafter (boy, I've got a lot to say!)
That's all I've used for the last 20 years or so.
I carry FFD's etc but rarely use them, they are there more for the 'what if?' factor.
I was a shift first aider, for 18 years and frankly, lost count of the number of times, I had to TEMPORARILY close ( often very nasty) wounds.
The thing that is important here; is to realise that any wound, that needs closing in this manner, needs to be checked by a doctor or at least a qualified nurse, as soon as possible.
R.B.
I carry FFD's etc but rarely use them, they are there more for the 'what if?' factor.
I was a shift first aider, for 18 years and frankly, lost count of the number of times, I had to TEMPORARILY close ( often very nasty) wounds.
The thing that is important here; is to realise that any wound, that needs closing in this manner, needs to be checked by a doctor or at least a qualified nurse, as soon as possible.
R.B.
TBH I've cut myself like that and the pain is sort of cancelled out when it's such a large cut so I can understand why he did it but it was kind of stupid to do it without the consultation of a professional.The reason he did it was because he was shooting a bow the next day for filming with Discovery but I'm not sure if many of you saw this video because it's quite interesting!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cF06utNBymQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cF06utNBymQ
Never done this myself nor would I even attempt it.
The worst I have done is when I inflicted a nasty deep cut on my left thumb whilst sharpening a sickle (the wrong way I guess)
I couldn't be bothered to take it down to casualty so after washing it I just put an absorbent dressing on, taped it up very firmly so it would not bend and left it for a couple of days to fester.
Seemed to have done the job and it healed up nicely.
The worst I have done is when I inflicted a nasty deep cut on my left thumb whilst sharpening a sickle (the wrong way I guess)
I couldn't be bothered to take it down to casualty so after washing it I just put an absorbent dressing on, taped it up very firmly so it would not bend and left it for a couple of days to fester.
Seemed to have done the job and it healed up nicely.
especcially in a hand wich is a complex piece of art ,with sinew, mussel and tissue, a lot can go wrong, if been cut trough to the bone, as Dave says, chances are you cut one of these, chances are ,some fingers will never work again.
3
320
Guest
Sounds like a job for......
actually duct tape and paper towels (or gauze pads) were my doctor's suggestion for even semi-serious lacerations. just be sure to irrigate ithe wound. clean water or contact (saline)solution work fine.
without meaning to wind anyone up, i've used super glue for years. irrigation seems to be the critical part of this self aid. anything left in the wound will encapsulate. resulting in excessive scarring or infection. super glue generates a lot of heat as it cures, dermabond and petbond less so, because of different formulae, providing an antiseptic effect.
the first aid kit i carry has duct tape, contact solution, super glue, telfa pads and pressure wraps. originally this stuff was for my dogs injuries. the glue is wonderful for head and face wounds. i've patched them and myself up many times and it seems to have had no ill effects.
