From what i can make out, the OP feels he would like to be able to carry any knife he likes, as he would enjoy the freedom to do so, However he also feels that certain branches of society, the villains, should not be able to carry knives at all, and he feels this would curtail the levels of knife crime prevalent in society, and he agrees that certain types of knife should be banned, which they are at the moment, he feels also that although the present knife laws are against his freedom, he feels that they are neccessary to curb knife violence.
Although the present knife laws have been in force for some time, the level of knife crime seems to be still going up.......................so obviously the villains are taking no notice of the present laws, and wont be bothered by any new ones..
Banning further types of knives, will in my opinion have no effect on the levels of knife crime....................................the majority of knife crime normally involves either home made knives or what we would call kitchen knives.
Unless all knives were banned, it is unlikely knife crime will ever decrease, and even then it is unlikely to do so.
There are many types of knives and sharp implements that are quite legal to carry, which could be used to kill or maim, so unless it was made illegal to carry any knife or sharp implement at all, it is unlikely that the levels of knife crime will abate. Anyone determined to cause havoc will find something to do it with whether its a knife, knitting needle, spike, etc, etc,
Knife crime itself is a major problem in society, and the Govt has to take steps to deal with it, up to now it has only shown knee jerk reactions, and as the level of crime continues to go up, then it is safe to assume it hasn't had the desired affect. The only affect the knife laws have had is on the likes of us who now think twice about carrying or showing our knives in public.
The OP asks for our opinions on the matter, and then argues against the points he does not agree with, which is what debating is all about, these questions have been asked many times on many forums, and there is in my opinion no answer, and if the Govt continues on the path it is on, we will find a lot of our freedoms restricted without it having any effect on knife crime itself.
Tackling the problems of gangs, depraved areas, lack of education and job prospects, are in my opinion some of the areas that need to be tackled, as well as higher custodial sentences for those found guilty of serious knife crimes.............................but all these need money to be spent, and that is unlikely to happen. Also we need full transparency with the reporting of knife related crime, for instance, what sort of knife was used, was it in a domestic setting, were both parties armed, etc, etc,
I also feel we need some sort of voice to protect our interests as bushcrafters, the public at large have no interest in our way of life, and to some we are seen as troublemakers, we appreciate the TV stars who carry on our way of life, but I dont remember any of them speaking up against the proposed laws regarding knives, so we are a minority, and we need to be noticed for the good things we do.