Ocean1975, I'll see if I can get a video up on youtube or something next time I practice the hand drill for you.
The hand drill may be easier in arid climates but it is still possible to achieve a high rate of success in temperate forest zones with the right materials and enough practice under your belt. What's more, native peoples could have worked in pairs or teams to produce fire using the hand-drill which makes it much, much easier. I don't know much on the exact history of friction firelighting methods in various parts of the world, whether the bow-drill came to replace the hand-drill in europe as a firelighting tool or not, or when that happened if it did, so if anybody has information on this to share it'd be fantastic to know the answers to these questions.
The hand drill to me, is a lot more satisfying due to its simplicity in having just two components and not requiring any cordage which is time-consuming to make. It's a more compact and lighter system for travel and its reliability depends on the skill level of the user, so it has the potential to be just as reliable as the bow drill. After mastering the hand drill, you would choose it over the bow drill any day and I feel it's a skill worth mastering, even if that takes over a year of regular practice. I'd love to get to that point, where I can have as much confidence in a hand drill set as I do in a box of matches. The floating technique, in my opinion, is definitely the way forwards to making the hand drill a truly reliable firemaking tool, just my 2 cents on the matter
The hand drill may be easier in arid climates but it is still possible to achieve a high rate of success in temperate forest zones with the right materials and enough practice under your belt. What's more, native peoples could have worked in pairs or teams to produce fire using the hand-drill which makes it much, much easier. I don't know much on the exact history of friction firelighting methods in various parts of the world, whether the bow-drill came to replace the hand-drill in europe as a firelighting tool or not, or when that happened if it did, so if anybody has information on this to share it'd be fantastic to know the answers to these questions.
The hand drill to me, is a lot more satisfying due to its simplicity in having just two components and not requiring any cordage which is time-consuming to make. It's a more compact and lighter system for travel and its reliability depends on the skill level of the user, so it has the potential to be just as reliable as the bow drill. After mastering the hand drill, you would choose it over the bow drill any day and I feel it's a skill worth mastering, even if that takes over a year of regular practice. I'd love to get to that point, where I can have as much confidence in a hand drill set as I do in a box of matches. The floating technique, in my opinion, is definitely the way forwards to making the hand drill a truly reliable firemaking tool, just my 2 cents on the matter