I like a cheery fire, but "crackle logs" can be bought quite cheaply and give a good few hours light. In the arctic a fire is useful for drying gear, melting snow and communal warmth and if a few shelters are placed around the fire then everyone gets the benefit IMO. However I always have a stove too for if conditions are poor or just a quick brew is needed. I agree with the OP in some respects. On our recent trip north, we relied on our kit to keep us warm and comfy, which it did to -34c with no fire. But early evening saw us getting a fire going because we had visitors and there was usually a stew and brew on the go at once which was easier on the coals... It was just nice to sit around...
