Minotaur said:
I must be missing something.
A billhook is a tool for chopping sticks up to an inch and half thick. A task mine accomplises with easy. It is a forestry tool, which makes it perfect for use in the UK and I would of thought most of the rest of Northern Europe.
The thing I do not get is people wanting it to be lighter. Is this the hammer thing re-visted? It is heavy so you do not have to do a lot of the work. They should be used like an axe or a hammer. I really must be missing something because my thinking goes but buy something else which would suit your use better i.e. a machette.
I do not think of my billhook as a replacement axe but as a better choice for the enviroment I use it in. In theory anything you can do with a small axe, I can do with a billhook. If it needs a big axe, I have a bow saw, uses less energy. It is actually an interesting question of what do you use your axe etc(The choppy part of your kit) for?
Well billhooks come in all shapes and sizes, (well probably more so in the past, less so now, unfortunately.) The lighest billhook I've used was a handmade Hedgehog (maker, unfortunately company long since ceased), which I picked up at a carboot for 50p. Was smaller than the modern billhooks, but far better made. Hedgehog ceased to trade well over 50 years ago (iirc), and this little billhook is still doing the job.
My yorkshire has a 9" straight edge, so tree with a larger diameter I use an axe and/or bowsaw or even occasionally a two person crosscut saw.
Also when coppicing a tree, I sometimes use an axe, as it leaves a smoother surface, whereas a saw would leave grooves where water could pool and harm the tree.
Can't do this with a billhook, as need a long handle to get the axe head close to the ground.