I think the Canadian ones look 'architeched', while the hobbit ones look organic
I think the Canadian ones are beautiful but the hobbit ones are magical
I think the Canadian ones are energy rich, but the hobbit ones are part of their surroundings re fuel, food and waste.
I think the Canadian ones cost over 10 times the price of the hobbit one.
I think the Canadian ones don't fit into their environment while the hobbit ones belong there.
I think the Canadian ones would be an awful lot easier to clean
but I don't think you'd notice in the hobbit one if someone did a bit of carving beside the hearth
cheers,
Toddy