He seemed a very nice guy, met him once in Gibraltar whilst we were in for repairs in 2000. He was there on holiday with his wife, the first time he'd been there when his visit was cut short in '82. We were in the same restaurant and our CO popped across to say hello and introduce himself, he bought us a round of port and we toasted him. The rest of the people in the restaurant seemed slightly confused. The thing I found interesting was the split on his popularity, unfair criticism on his positioning and use of the carriers and his "there will be deaths and we will lose ships" speech. Let's face it for a scratch team (at least at the start) they didn't do bad. Fair winds and following seas.