MoD Survival Knife... Not such a pig afterall

  • BushMoot: Come along to the amazing Summer Moot 31st July - 5th August (extended Moot : 27th July - 8th August), a festival of bushcrafting and camping in a beautiful woodland PLEASE CLICK HERE for more information.

Smig73

New Member
Jul 19, 2026
5
4
53
Barnsley
So, I've been procrastinating for a while now but finally took the plunge and bought a J.Adams MoD Survival Knife.

I already own a couple of decent bushcraft knives, nothing fancy or expensive and I also have a nice Bowie from the 1970's. I'm from South Yorkshire so I've been raised on the sure and certain knowledge that the best knives are made in Sheffield and fortunately for all concerned that still includes examples of the MoD Survival Knife, though the various makers have long since been absorbed by a single manufacturer.


The fact is the knife is quite a crude tool but the steel is good and there's plenty of it so my intention was always to try some minor modifications.

1) Remove the finger guard - Quite frankly the worst feature on the knife. Tack welded into place and it inhibits the placement of your thumb on the spine, should you want a modicum of better control.

2) Reprofile the scales - Their quite thick and angular and not at all suitable for my tiny delicate girl hands.

3) With the guard removed I thought it wise to form a finger choil. The tang/blade is a thick piece of steel but this was surprisingly easy with a Dremel set on medium speed.

4) Jimping - Using a diamond needle file, I've cut 3 good grooves into the spine. I'd already ground out a smooth transition from the tang to the spine where the steel had previously had a step to hold the guard. 3 grooves feel more than adequate for the size of my hands and fingers.

5) Sheath - OMG! The sheath that comes with the knife is truly dreadful. It's a perfectly good piece of leather but it's definitely a product of the same thinking that went into the finger guard. The worst part is the location of the snap, right up near the top of the belt loop. Should the whole assembly be turned upside down for any reason, the knife slides out, exposing a good 3" section of blade. I tried to commission an Etsy maker to create a nice leather sheath, configured for scout carry, but he's no longer doing custom jobs. I ended up getting a decent nylon sheath (Marauder) from eBay for a fraction of the cost.

6) Para-chord - A final touch was knotting a length of para-chord.





 
I have the Webtex one, much better guard (properly fitted between handle and blade).

Don't forget to reprofile the blade to remove mass, I gave mine a high convex grind and it makes a decent chopper.

On your knife the high grind would start just above the NATO marking arrow.

Can also use the Dremel to put a fire steel scraper notch in back of the blade to save using main blade for scraping.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Smig73
The original handles on these were atrocious things and always best fettled into something useable or replaced completely. For a man (i.e someone without little girlie hands ;) ) they worked well enough as choppers, but were even better suited to battoning though firewood. A regrind to a high sabre can make them more user-friendly, but if you're going to that amount of work you may as well make something better instead IMO.
The work done by the OP has certainly made it a more useable tool though.

I believe many canoeists found them eminently useful when fitted with a long length of paracord...

Well... a fella in a boat can always find a use for an anchor :lol:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Smig73
Very nice job by the poster but it remains a bit of a pig if it needs so much fettling to bring up to scratch

If only the MOD or Rogers would stop tendering the same contract drawings but modernising it like above. With some of the changes there's actually less manufacturing and costs!
 
I have the Webtex one, much better guard (properly fitted between handle and blade).

Don't forget to reprofile the blade to remove mass, I gave mine a high convex grind and it makes a decent chopper.

On your knife the high grind would start just above the NATO marking arrow.

Can also use the Dremel to put a fire steel scraper notch in back of the blade to save using main blade for scraping.
The spine is filed to a decent 90 degree edge and it throws out plenty of sparks from my fero-rods.

I may increase the size of the finger choil and perhaps take a little more material off the scales.

For now it all feels pretty comfortable.
 
Very nice job by the poster but it remains a bit of a pig if it needs so much fettling to bring up to scratch

If only the MOD or Rogers would stop tendering the same contract drawings but modernising it like above. With some of the changes there's actually less manufacturing and c

Very nice job by the poster but it remains a bit of a pig if it needs so much fettling to bring up to scratch

If only the MOD or Rogers would stop tendering the same contract drawings but modernising it like above. With some of the changes there's actually less manufacturing and costs!
I couldn't agree more. Part of my motivation to buy the knife was simply pandering to nostalgia, in respect of both a knife pattern used by the British military and one manufactured in the Steel City. I was close to paying for a vintage original that dated back to the early 80's but decided that at the asking price I wouldn't be inclined to put it to any use.

I think that the blank represents a very good starting point that with some refinement could make for a very good product, especially for export to countries that have fundamentally more sensible legislature pertaining to knives. A deeper convex grind, a wider range of handle scales (with a slimmer profile), jimping, finger and sharpening choils and a choice of better quality more functional sheaths. When you look at the prices some people are prepared to pay for good knives and then consider the history of Sheffield knife making, I definitely think that Sheffield Knives are missing an opportunity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CLEM
! briefly owned one of these fifteen plus years ago, I think it was an earlier version than the one in the OP.
I disliked it from the second it arrived and sold it on. I really have no idea what the MoD were trying to achieve.
 
I believe you can buy a factory modded version of the MOD now, inspired by a YouTuber who modded the MOD few years ago now.
 
It’s tidied up nicely but does amaze me that people are buying them to start with.

There are definitely cheaper project knives out there.

You could commission a better knife than that for not much more money, especially if you asked for it to be left unfinished in the handle for you to shape to taste.
 
It’s tidied up nicely but does amaze me that people are buying them to start with.

There are definitely cheaper project knives out there.

You could commission a better knife than that for not much more money, especially if you asked for it to be left unfinished in the handle for you to shape to taste.
True, but then I do like to try doing things myself
 
! briefly owned one of these fifteen plus years ago, I think it was an earlier version than the one in the OP.
I disliked it from the second it arrived and sold it on. I really have no idea what the MoD were trying to achieve.
From what I’ve gleaned it was always intended to be somewhat of a lump, likely to survive all manner of abuse while able to take a reasonable edge.

I have no particular skill when it comes to sharpening and even I can get it sharp in no time at all.

There’s a good video from Dutch Bushcraft boys that demonstrates just how tough it is while also showing its lack of refinement.

All in, mine is a work in progress but so far I’m reasonably happy with the product and the project.
 
True, but then I do like to try doing things myself
I totally get it. You could actually commission it to the level you want and then possibly pay less though.

I wish I could make and sell poorly finished knives with people willing to pay that amount to then happily rework.
I would sell a ‘kit’ for less than that cost you.
 
I've tried in the past, with varying amounts of success, you could buy kits - I forget where from. Unfortunately I no longer have the workshop facilities I had back then. I've got a 19 year old Alan Wood DP bushcrafter that is an exquisite piece of work and is my main knife - carefully used, I had to wait over a year to get it! Also a couple of Mark Hill knives that I will sell at some point. I tend to use Mora knives for everyday work, they're cheap and bloody good value imo.
 
Last edited:

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE