So, I'm man enough to admit when I am completely wrong (afterall it doesn't happen very often
).
I went out the other day, and cut some dead birch rounds to bring home to try to test out each of my axes: A Gerber Extra Large, a Wetterlings Large Hunter (older with rounded poll), and the new GB Outdoors Axe that is the the subject of this thread.
So based on some of the reading I did, I decided to cut the logs pretty short to make it easier to practice. So I wound up with three 5-6" diameter logs, and six 3-4" diameter logs, all of short stature.
The Gerber XL sliced through them with little trouble due to its weight and size. I must say I did find it a little awkward feeling. The hollow handle made the balance of the axe feel quite strange.
The Wetterlings axe I knew might not be great, so here is where I tried to bring some knowledge to the table. I watched a
Ray Mears video of him showing axe use, which I have seen before and was always kind of blown away how the wood just seemed to blow apart with little to no effort. I decided to give it a go, and man did I get great results! I recently sharpened this axe so that could have been a factor as well (since I bought used it was probably pretty blunt my first few goes with it). Had little to no trouble splitting this birch with very little effort.
Then onto the GB Outdoor. I again attempted the technique of throwing the top of the axe head to the side, and the result?
The GB performed marvelously. The with a quick turn of the head, and enough speed the wood easily split apart without the axe digging into the block and blunting the blade. One or two strikes was all it would take. I think given the right wood choice in the bush, this axe will perform just fine for splitting tasks.
I do plan on splitting the rest of the big stuff down further to have a supply for my honey stove if we want to go to the beach and have a cook up. My only complaint is I do think it really is an inch or two too short to truly use comfortably as a two handed axe. I did it, but it felt very forced. I think I will be happy with my current selection of axes for now, and will try this GB out in the field in a couple of weeks. Splitting small logs in the backyard on a proper block and splitting in the woods when you need to get a fire going is another story.
Thanks Tiley and everyone for all the helpful info and links. I think this is a good resource for the GB Outdoor, as I had quite a bit of trouble finding info when I was originally considering buying it.
I'll update when I try it in the field.
H