Experiments with ChatGPT

  • Hey Guest, Early bird pricing on the Summer Moot (29th July - 10th August) available until April 6th, we'd love you to come. PLEASE CLICK HERE to early bird price and get more information.

Broch

Life Member
Jan 18, 2009
8,064
7,856
Mid Wales
www.mont-hmg.co.uk
Experiments with ChatGPT

I am intrigued by the idea of AI conversations and so I’ve finally got around to trying out ChatGPT.

First, I asked about the discovery and development of fire by mankind. Naïve questions resulted in relatively simple and shallow answers but, as in real conversations, probing and questioning the answers led to more depth and interesting responses.

I then asked about the development of the bow in Europe – I had to push to get answers about pre-history but I had not been specific – again, ambiguity in the question results in less useful information.

Then I asked what ephemeral ponds are and how I would create them – some good and useful responses that would enable anyone to start using them in conservation resulted.

Finally, I decided to question rewilding… here are the results (the bold is my question):

What is the definition of rewilding?

Rewilding is a conservation approach that involves restoring and protecting natural ecosystems and allowing them to function without human interference. The goal of rewilding is to promote biodiversity, restore natural ecological processes, and create self-sustaining ecosystems that are capable of functioning without ongoing human intervention. This often involves reintroducing species that have been lost or removed from an area, removing barriers to natural processes such as river restoration, and reducing human impact through measures such as reduced hunting and logging. Rewilding can be applied to a range of landscapes, from forests and wetlands to grasslands and oceans.

How is browsing used in rewilding?

Browsing is a term used in ecology to describe the feeding behavior of certain herbivorous animals, such as deer and elk, that consume leaves, stems, and twigs of woody plants. In the context of rewilding, browsing can play a role in promoting ecosystem health and biodiversity.

In some cases, reintroducing browsing animals to an area that has been degraded or altered by human activity can help restore the natural balance of the ecosystem. For example, by removing overgrown vegetation, browsing animals can create open areas that allow sunlight to reach the forest floor, promoting the growth of new plant species and providing habitat for other wildlife. Additionally, the presence of browsing animals can help control invasive plant species and prevent them from taking over an ecosystem.

However, it's important to note that the use of browsing animals in rewilding must be carefully managed to ensure that they do not cause unintended harm to the ecosystem. Overgrazing by browsing animals can lead to degradation of the ecosystem, so it's important to monitor their populations and adjust management practices accordingly.

Is it possible to apply rewilding principles without browsing animals?

Yes, it is possible to apply rewilding principles without the use of browsing animals. While browsing animals can play an important role in promoting ecosystem health and biodiversity in certain contexts, rewilding is a flexible approach that can be adapted to different ecosystems and situations.

Other rewilding techniques include the restoration of wetlands, the reintroduction of native plant species, the removal of invasive species, the reduction of human impact, and the creation of wildlife corridors to connect fragmented habitats. These techniques can all contribute to the restoration and protection of natural ecosystems, even in the absence of browsing animals.

Ultimately, the specific techniques used in rewilding will depend on the particular ecosystem and the goals of the rewilding project. The most effective approach will likely involve a combination of techniques tailored to the specific needs of the ecosystem.

Is leaving land to go wild the same as rewilding?

Leaving land to go wild is not necessarily the same as rewilding. While both may involve the restoration and protection of natural ecosystems, there are some important differences.

Leaving land to go wild is a passive approach that involves simply allowing an area to revert to a natural state without human intervention. This may occur naturally if an area is left undisturbed for an extended period of time, or it may be a deliberate choice to allow an area to return to a natural state.

Rewilding, on the other hand, is an active approach that involves a deliberate effort to restore and protect natural ecosystems and promote biodiversity. This may involve interventions such as the reintroduction of native species, the removal of invasive species, or the creation of wildlife corridors to connect fragmented habitats.

While leaving land to go wild can result in the restoration of natural ecosystems over time, rewilding is a more proactive approach that can speed up the restoration process and help to ensure the long-term health and sustainability of the ecosystem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nice65 and TeeDee

TeeDee

Full Member
Nov 6, 2008
10,499
3,702
50
Exeter
Experiments with ChatGPT

I am intrigued by the idea of AI conversations and so I’ve finally got around to trying out ChatGPT.

First, I asked about the discovery and development of fire by mankind. Naïve questions resulted in relatively simple and shallow answers but, as in real conversations, probing and questioning the answers led to more depth and interesting responses.

I then asked about the development of the bow in Europe – I had to push to get answers about pre-history but I had not been specific – again, ambiguity in the question results in less useful information.

Then I asked what ephemeral ponds are and how I would create them – some good and useful responses that would enable anyone to start using them in conservation resulted.

Finally, I decided to question rewilding… here are the results (the bold is my question):

What is the definition of rewilding?

Rewilding is a conservation approach that involves restoring and protecting natural ecosystems and allowing them to function without human interference. The goal of rewilding is to promote biodiversity, restore natural ecological processes, and create self-sustaining ecosystems that are capable of functioning without ongoing human intervention. This often involves reintroducing species that have been lost or removed from an area, removing barriers to natural processes such as river restoration, and reducing human impact through measures such as reduced hunting and logging. Rewilding can be applied to a range of landscapes, from forests and wetlands to grasslands and oceans.

How is browsing used in rewilding?

Browsing is a term used in ecology to describe the feeding behavior of certain herbivorous animals, such as deer and elk, that consume leaves, stems, and twigs of woody plants. In the context of rewilding, browsing can play a role in promoting ecosystem health and biodiversity.

In some cases, reintroducing browsing animals to an area that has been degraded or altered by human activity can help restore the natural balance of the ecosystem. For example, by removing overgrown vegetation, browsing animals can create open areas that allow sunlight to reach the forest floor, promoting the growth of new plant species and providing habitat for other wildlife. Additionally, the presence of browsing animals can help control invasive plant species and prevent them from taking over an ecosystem.

However, it's important to note that the use of browsing animals in rewilding must be carefully managed to ensure that they do not cause unintended harm to the ecosystem. Overgrazing by browsing animals can lead to degradation of the ecosystem, so it's important to monitor their populations and adjust management practices accordingly.

Is it possible to apply rewilding principles without browsing animals?

Yes, it is possible to apply rewilding principles without the use of browsing animals. While browsing animals can play an important role in promoting ecosystem health and biodiversity in certain contexts, rewilding is a flexible approach that can be adapted to different ecosystems and situations.

Other rewilding techniques include the restoration of wetlands, the reintroduction of native plant species, the removal of invasive species, the reduction of human impact, and the creation of wildlife corridors to connect fragmented habitats. These techniques can all contribute to the restoration and protection of natural ecosystems, even in the absence of browsing animals.

Ultimately, the specific techniques used in rewilding will depend on the particular ecosystem and the goals of the rewilding project. The most effective approach will likely involve a combination of techniques tailored to the specific needs of the ecosystem.

Is leaving land to go wild the same as rewilding?

Leaving land to go wild is not necessarily the same as rewilding. While both may involve the restoration and protection of natural ecosystems, there are some important differences.

Leaving land to go wild is a passive approach that involves simply allowing an area to revert to a natural state without human intervention. This may occur naturally if an area is left undisturbed for an extended period of time, or it may be a deliberate choice to allow an area to return to a natural state.

Rewilding, on the other hand, is an active approach that involves a deliberate effort to restore and protect natural ecosystems and promote biodiversity. This may involve interventions such as the reintroduction of native species, the removal of invasive species, or the creation of wildlife corridors to connect fragmented habitats.

While leaving land to go wild can result in the restoration of natural ecosystems over time, rewilding is a more proactive approach that can speed up the restoration process and help to ensure the long-term health and sustainability of the ecosystem.


So what do you feel about the takeaway feeling of it - is it a myriad of plagiarized comments drawn together from the internet or something more?
 

Broch

Life Member
Jan 18, 2009
8,064
7,856
Mid Wales
www.mont-hmg.co.uk
It feels like more. I went on, and asked questions about AI in a more conversational way and it picked up on nuance and discussion references in a very natural way - accepting limitations, concerns and unknowns but creating good structured arguments.

My son has used it to generate runnable code from a simple specification of input and output (don't start a coding career now) and a short story from a character definition.

It is fascinating - and just the beginning :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TeeDee

Laurentius

Bushcrafter (boy, I've got a lot to say!)
Aug 13, 2009
2,428
619
Knowhere
I have been experimenting with chat GPT too, and it is disappointing, it cannot drive a tank or even learn from a book how to, never mind hack into a system controlling tanks, but then it would say that wouldn't it. On the whole it has limited access probably for commercial and copyright reasons to the resources it claims and where it does not know the answer it bluffs. It is the bluffing that is the dangerous thing, but for the most part I have questioned it on things I am expert in and found it very wanting. If any of you have heard of Williams syndrome, this is essentially what it is, that is having a great facility in simulating the niceties of social discourse but at the expense of fact.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: Broch and Souledman

Laurentius

Bushcrafter (boy, I've got a lot to say!)
Aug 13, 2009
2,428
619
Knowhere
I have been experimenting with chat GPT too, and it is disappointing, it cannot drive a tank or even learn from a book how to, never mind hack into a system controlling tanks, but then it would say that wouldn't it. On the whole it has limited access probably for commercial and copyright reasons to the resources it claims and where it does not know the answer it bluffs. It is the bluffing that is the dangerous thing, but for the most part I have questioned it on things I am expert in and found it very wanting. If any of you have heard of Williams syndrome, this is essentially what it is, that is having a great facility in simulating the niceties of social discourse but at the expense of fact.
Oh and it can write a good horoscope :)
 

Jared

Bushcrafter (boy, I've got a lot to say!)
Sep 8, 2005
3,403
643
50
Wales

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE