Carinthia Survival One or Carinthia Survival Down?

  • Hey Guest, Early bird pricing on the Summer Moot (29th July - 10th August) available until April 6th, we'd love you to come. PLEASE CLICK HERE to early bird price and get more information.

Greek1983

Forager
Jan 23, 2011
206
0
Athens, Greece
My first thread! :D

Alright, I am about to go for a true winter sleeping bag. Already owning and tested the Observer Plus bivy tent and the Defence 1 from the same company, I am in a dilemma of choosing either a synthetic-filled bag or a down-filled one. I read a lot of threads here on BCUK and had a talk over several other forums over this subject, still I can't decide which one to go for.

Problem #1: I have a 65 lt backpack from my military service, and if I go for the Survival One I will definitely need a much larger rucksack, whereas with the Survival Down won't need a new purchase.

Problem #2: Down is not moisture-proof, whereas synthetic is hydrophobic.

Even though here in Greece we don't get that low temperatures, a lot of backpackers prefer down over synthetic. I was thinking of making a "system", that is using the Defence 1 as an overbag and go for the Survival Down and pack it in a waterproof stuff sack. Or mate the Down bag with the bivy tent.

In case you might ask why I opt for these models, I like the idea of centre-zip bag and integrated sleeves and thus do some basic stuff without the need of getting in and out of the bag. Don't think I'll ever be a sniper hidden in the snow and use it as a coat. :)
 

Topcat1308

Tenderfoot
Feb 9, 2011
55
1
Wirral
I use the Defence 4 so I'm familiar with the quality of their gear - My own preference is that I have never gone for down whether that be a jacket or a sleeping system. - comfy and warm and pack well but next to useless if soaked through.

All depends what you're going to be getting upto - but I know the first time I want to rely on a down product it will get soaked somehow with no way of drying it and Ill freeze and be eaten by wolves...im a persistent victim of sods law
 

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE