Just been going back over this thread , and with ref to feedback;-
"Before we get to the order stage Kevin wants to complete the prototype, finish it to a high standard (hems and edges finished properly, neck-tie completed etc) and to test it. He would also appreciate sensible feedback as to changes and optional additions. I have some photos and some thoughts I have already passed onto him.
My thoughts as to changes to the shirt:
Reduce the volume of the rear of the hood (ie get rid of the pointy bit at the back and round it out - see piccie 3 below)
Slightly reduce the bulk/volume of the upper arms/shoulders
Lower the 'roo pocket by 4 inches
Put 'darts' in the seams bottom left and right to aid movement and relieve stress at these points - the point I mean is where the longer back joins the shorter front on each side - you can see where I mean in piccie 4.
Don't use metal eyelets for the lace closure but stitched/thread holes as in my experience metal eyelets pull through the material over time. "
Reduce Hood - In doing this , will you still be able to turn ones head and the hood stay in situ ontop of your head? aslong as it does not problem , Also a 'slightly' more voluminous hood allows you to wear a hat ( think ruski cossack style ) and the hood can increase to sit ontop of that.
You want to be able to easily turn your head and the hood to follow.
Im just thinking about the Temperature and conditions where this bit of kit should ( in theory ) get most use.
Reduce Upper Arm, Shoulder material - Again in doing this , as long as the coat does not 'lift' when reaching over head with arms , good mobility of shoulder joint should be unrestricted for bushy type activity , it will also create extra 'air' pockets to store heat around thermal core.
Lower Roo pocket - Cant comment , if it makes sense , do it. This is going to a very individual thing of where all our hands ergonomically 'lay' at ease.
Darts - Makes sense to increase movement , bending down , taking high steps to clear logs etc.
Eyelets - Good point. Metal ringlets would also get very cold.#
The only contribution i can make is i think the overall length is spot on, it should ride down to just behind the knee's , so that when sitting down all the back material does not vanish and you have something to sit upon.
Possibly even double it up?
Good that it goes down past the groin area aswell.
If a chest pocketwas included with the kangaroo pockets , ist it possible , just for aesthetics for it to be made the same template as the pockets themselves , so that you dont have an obvious square patch just sewed on to the front of the pocket? Either that or put the chest pocket in behind the chest pocket with a slit opening at the top , this would keep any weighty stored items closer to someone centre of gravity , and so stop them bouncing around so much.
Suggestion of a Waist drawcord? Again to keep an active 'hot' air pocket in close to the main core area.
Going to see if i can find a copy of Mors 'dressing for the boreal forest' PDF and post a link.
##found it##
http://www.karamat.com/articles/pdf files/dressing001.pdf
You can see on the sketch where the HHLA ( High Heat Loss Areas) are considered to be , Armpits and Groin area, so I would consider keeping the extra material at the armpits/shoulders and ensure that the front of the smock is just above the knee's.
Hope this helps. Happy to go with the common gorup decision , just offering some feedback as requested.