Probably the same reason as the stick tang . Resource was at a premium, so if it isn’t super necessary then it’s not there
Why most Leukus does not have guard ?
- Thread starter Urdasein
- Start date
Finnish puukkos have traditionally never had finger guard because it´s in the way when carving and making stuff with the knife. So say our puukko-historians who have studied the matter.
One factor is that the present day puukko is a tool and has been developed from a tool, a guard just would be in the way as Herman said.
As speculation it might be that knives with guards have a weapon or hunting knife heritage where guards do have a distinct function.
As speculation it might be that knives with guards have a weapon or hunting knife heritage where guards do have a distinct function.
I would suggest the lack of finger guard on Scandinavian designs is about the expectation of the user as in a skilled knife operative - not someone who is not skilled enough to keep their fingers away from the cutting edge.
In addition there are knife operations that would be hindered by the presence of a finger guard, where what are these Scandinavian designs for if not general purpose duties, say from preparing dinner to what have you.
Where it does have to be said, an unguarded knife teaches one both blade respect and knife skills potentially quickly.
For a while my Frosts of Mora (Mora Classic) lived in my kitchen drawer as the goto knife for food prep.
In addition there are knife operations that would be hindered by the presence of a finger guard, where what are these Scandinavian designs for if not general purpose duties, say from preparing dinner to what have you.
Where it does have to be said, an unguarded knife teaches one both blade respect and knife skills potentially quickly.
For a while my Frosts of Mora (Mora Classic) lived in my kitchen drawer as the goto knife for food prep.
You need to learn how to hold that knife for the intended purpose. It isn't a Rambo pig-sticker. Select the correct knife for the job.
Pacific Northwest crooked and straight knives never have any kinds of guards.
Useless additions to how they are held and used. Same for all cleavers, ulu and umialik knives.
Pacific Northwest crooked and straight knives never have any kinds of guards.
Useless additions to how they are held and used. Same for all cleavers, ulu and umialik knives.
I was taught that if you need a guard then you are either looking for a fight or do not know how to use a knife!
I like a small "finger choil" but no guard or riccasso ... moderate knife skills?
I like a small "finger choil" but no guard or riccasso ... moderate knife skills?
You are refering to the "chef knife grip". It is true that a finger guard may get in the way.
In fact it depends on the knife.
The Junglas II is basically a little bit too thick butcher knife. And it works very well as chef knife too.
I also Use the BK7/M7/Esee6 for cooking without finding the guard cumbersome...
Last edited:
When wandering around, I "need" a tool that is as multi-purpose as possible.
Selecting the correct "tool" for the job implies specialized tools implies to be sendentary or having the ability / need to carry such additionnal weight.
(please don't tell me that I should split logs with an axe because I may answer you to carry a splitting maul in your backpack =)
Last edited:
You are making king-size fires if a maul is needed for the fire wood.
In most of Scandinavia an axe is not needed for fire making, normal knife is enough.
I agree with you all. There are times when the knife has to be multipurpose.
Wood carving tools might be one extreme, doing most kitchen prep with 5 cleavers in 2 sizes might be another specialization.
In a camp, preparing food or cleaning game, that one knife must do everything, just keep it sharp.
Wood carving tools might be one extreme, doing most kitchen prep with 5 cleavers in 2 sizes might be another specialization.
In a camp, preparing food or cleaning game, that one knife must do everything, just keep it sharp.
I mean such finger guards, that make a knife pretty useless as kitchen knife.
www.bw-discount.de
But I already had problems with a knife that was similar to this:
www.marttiini.fi
And also this is not good in the kitchen:
www.hultafors.de
BW Kampfmesser oliv zerlegbar nach orig. TL
Das Bundeswehr Kampfmesser oliv ist seit Jahren eines der beliebtesten Outdoor Messer beim Campen, bei der Jagd oder zum Angeln. Das BW Messer wird…
www.bw-discount.de
But I already had problems with a knife that was similar to this:
Deluxe Classic
And also this is not good in the kitchen:
Outdoor Messer OK4 | Hultafors Tools
Ein kraftvolles und haltbares Outdoormesser mit einem rutschsicheren Griff für anspruchsvolle Arbeiten. Die textile, robuste Gürtelschlaufe macht es möglich das Messer auch an bis zu 80mm breiten Gürteln zu befestigen und hat eine Schlaufe für einen Feuerstahl. Die Klinge hat einen Scandischliff...
www.hultafors.de
That Hultafors knife might be really good in the kitchen. Saw off the finger guard. Use rasps and files and sandpapers to smooth the new surface. But there are lots of much better choices without the added work of reshaping the knife.
If I would change the finger guard, I had to make a new sheath.
The knife is a good recommendation, and surely the GK heavy duty too, especially regarding the price. But that's a reason to prefere the Morakniv Companion heavy duty instead of it, or whatever.
The knife is a good recommendation, and surely the GK heavy duty too, especially regarding the price. But that's a reason to prefere the Morakniv Companion heavy duty instead of it, or whatever.