Reprofiling a blade

Draven

Native
Jul 8, 2006
1,530
6
35
Scotland
Howdy folks
Just wondering, if you reprofile a blade from, say, hollow ground double bevel to a scandi grind, and you use a file rather than a grinder, is there any lasting damage caused to the blade?
Thanks!
Pete

EDIT: just changed subject so it can be found by others asking the same question..
 

C_Claycomb

Moderator staff
Mod
Oct 6, 2003
7,633
2,709
Bedfordshire
First off a matter of semantics. What you are talking about is altering the grind of the knife, not its profile. Profile refers to how the knife looks from the side...what you would have to cut out of sheet stock if you were making it from scratch.

There are a number of problems with doing what you suggest. First, if the steel is worth fooling with, there probably won't be all that much of a hardness difference between the blade and a file, so it will be hard going. It is sertainly do-able, but not a lot of fun. Secondly, if it is a high hollow grind you may not have enough metal to make a neat job of it...you may end up with the correct scandi bevel, but still have some hollow showing. I don't see that this would me a problem, but it would look odd.

None of this will hurt the blade. The only way to really damage a blade is to get it too hot, this will soften it a little, rather like an extension of tempering, but you need to be getting to around 170degC to start worrying about that, easier to do with a grinder than a file. Scratches may look bad but things like that can be sanded out and won't hurt the performance of the blade unduely, just how it looks.

What is the knife that you are looking at? What stock thickness and steel type? Some steels aren't going to work with a file at all, others will be (relatively) easier.
 

Draven

Native
Jul 8, 2006
1,530
6
35
Scotland
First off a matter of semantics. What you are talking about is altering the grind of the knife, not its profile. Profile refers to how the knife looks from the side...what you would have to cut out of sheet stock if you were making it from scratch.

Hmmm... dang, that's a bit embarrassing :p

The reason I ask is that I'm thinking about buying this and/or this (assuming they'll be restocked, cuz I'm broke right now) and it doesn't mention grinds, but I think they're hollow ground.
I don't care if these are really great blades, I'm only buying one for fun really, but I like all my knives to be functional... and after trying a knife that wasn't hollow ground, I don't consider hollow grinds to be very functional at all :rolleyes: Although An added bonus is that I'd like practice before I start hacking up an antler...

The seller says they're "high carbon steel stainless blades"... is that even possible? :eek: I always thought you had to choose between high carbon and stainless.

So in simple terms, filing won't hurt the performance of the blade (assuming I do it right) but it'll be lots of hard work and might look dodgy when I'm done?
 

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE