Some of the foods listed here seem really seem too normal to be listed (most actually) but since the tone has been set that way, I'll continue but separate them.
Normal foods:
Beef
Lamb
Pork (domesticated)
Goat
Chicken
Turkey
Duck
Quail (wild and domesticated) and quail eggs (preferably pickled)
Rabbit (wild and domesticated)
Frog legs (wild and domesticated)
Deer (wild white tail)
Elk Summer Sausage
Buffalo (what you call bison; domesticated)
Crawfish
Shrimp
Catfish (freshwater)
Bream (freshwater)
Perch (freshwater)
Mussels (saltwater)
Oysters (saltwater) dozens of different ways but preferably dredged in flour and deep fried
Shark (saltwater)
Tuna (saltwater) canned and fresh
Mackeral (saltwater) canned and fresh-King mackeral and Spanish mackeral
Redfish (saltwater) fried and blackened
Swordfish (saltwater obviously)
Red Snapper (saltwater)
Dolphin (the fish not the mammal/saltwater) also called mahi mahi
Scallops (sea scallops and bay scallops)
Crab (Blue Crab, Snow Crab, Alaska King Crab, and soft shell Crab)
Salmon (freshwater phase) preferably Alaska Salmon
Tilapia (saltwater)
More exotic or less normal:
Conch (saltwater)
Tripe
Chitlins
Wild Boar (their taste isn't really predictable as they're omnivores and their diet changes week to week)
Squid and/or octopus (too chewy)
Steak and Kidney Pie (ate around the kidneys after trying one)
Several things in Saudi that just said "meat"
I'm sure I've forgotten loads.