Yes I totally agree. A major incident first responder kit is massive overkill for most people and situations. Hence my suggestion that people just use a regular first aid kit for around £40 or £50 from a reputable well known supplier then add a few extra items afterwards.
The only reason that we got a first responder kit was because we intended to separate the contents to create four totally separate first aid kits to put in four separate locations. We managed to do this (plus we added a few extra items too) all for a little over £200. When you consider what is included in each of the kits and the professional grade quality of the items it actually worked out as fair value when compared to buying four regular first aid kits separately.
I also totally agree about the various airway tubes which we put in the bin. But apart from those everything else is still there in one or other of the kits and we would be confident to use any of the other items if necessary.
I would never buy four “regular” FAKs, I would obtain four suitable containers, an old ice cream box will do, mark or sticker them “First Aid” and stock them with whatever items you think you would need for that particular application, activity or environment. I once bought a FAK for my business…….It contained 42 bandages! That was to purely to pack it out as cheap as possible, never bought another one.
My chainsaw/bushcraft kit does not contain any “normal” dressings, for bleeds it has two “Traumafix’ dressings, two Haemostatic dressings, vet wrap x 2 a few low adherent dressings, OTOM, small mirror, two Calico Triangular Bandages, and a Tourniquet. With vet wrap and low adherent dressings, I have all the bandages I need. Also some burns gel dressings. You don’t need to be spending £200, you really don’t.
My hiking kit: Vet wrap x 1, low adherent dressings, foils blanket, SAM splint, burns gel dressing, blister kit, OTOM, Tourniquet if you feel you need one.
I always have 300mg Asprin tablets for a suspected heart attack. Other meds in MY kit, Paracetamol, Anti Histamine cream and/or tablets, Ibrufen, Diarrhea tablets.
Generic items: Triangular bandages, Plasters, alcohol free moist wipes, ampules of sterile water and shears, you
MUST have shears!
Don’t forget, we are dealing with “First Aid” the initial assistance given to someone who is injured or ill, before the arrival of medical assistance. The most important thing you are going to do, is call for help, if needed, once you have carried out a Primary Survey.
On one of my CPD courses a Paramedic told me that if a casualty is not spraying blood everywhere, and is breathing, they have something to work with. KEEP IT SIMPLE! Get trained.
Very importantly, know how to recognise in yourself and someone else, and deal, with a heart attack.
I always asked the question to my learners “When was the last time you used a bandage?” Honest answers please.