Jak
I guess I'm saying that science may be the best way to answer certain questions, and if the question is " Does ingesting aluminium cause Alzheimer's disease?" then I don't see any other way. No matter how many years of experience you have working with people with Alzheimer's you won't be able to answer it without science. OTOH I'd much rather have an experienced care assistant working with me on a busy shift rather than any world famous neuro-scientist, even if he or she can explain in detail the latest research findings. So, looking after people with Alzheimer's, yup, experience matters, explaining it... give me science... Seeing the effects of Alzheimer's I want to take steps to lessen the chances I'll get it and again I have to look to science and scientists for that.
If the question is "why can't I get an ember from my bow drill?" there's any number of people on BCUK who could help me. So no argument when it comes to bushcraft, knowing how to do something because you've done it lots in different conditions is much better than knowing that it's possible to do it because you've read it in a book or a website. Mind you in learning about edible versus non-edible plants I prefer to use both, it's great to go munching the flora but only if I feel comfortable in my identification.... "What are these nice pink berry things?... racks brain... gets out book, aha Spindle... "Fruits are toxic in large quantities"" .. Thank you book. Experience may have taught people what's toxic, science will have worked out why.
I guess I'm saying that science may be the best way to answer certain questions, and if the question is " Does ingesting aluminium cause Alzheimer's disease?" then I don't see any other way. No matter how many years of experience you have working with people with Alzheimer's you won't be able to answer it without science. OTOH I'd much rather have an experienced care assistant working with me on a busy shift rather than any world famous neuro-scientist, even if he or she can explain in detail the latest research findings. So, looking after people with Alzheimer's, yup, experience matters, explaining it... give me science... Seeing the effects of Alzheimer's I want to take steps to lessen the chances I'll get it and again I have to look to science and scientists for that.
If the question is "why can't I get an ember from my bow drill?" there's any number of people on BCUK who could help me. So no argument when it comes to bushcraft, knowing how to do something because you've done it lots in different conditions is much better than knowing that it's possible to do it because you've read it in a book or a website. Mind you in learning about edible versus non-edible plants I prefer to use both, it's great to go munching the flora but only if I feel comfortable in my identification.... "What are these nice pink berry things?... racks brain... gets out book, aha Spindle... "Fruits are toxic in large quantities"" .. Thank you book. Experience may have taught people what's toxic, science will have worked out why.