My probably annual winter jacket recommendation thread!!

  • Hey Guest, We're having our annual Winter Moot and we'd love you to come. PLEASE LOOK HERE to secure your place and get more information.
    For forum threads CLICK HERE
The thing about parkas for men is they are almost the only way to get longer coats for less energetic uses like my use situation. Army surplus perhaps but modern puffer jackets for men are shorter length.

For women less of an issue. There's many brands from cheap to expensive that offer longer puffer jackets for women, usually fitted because all women want to show off their figure when it's cold and they're walking the dog in the dark, right?

AFAIK there's only one brand that will supply longer puffer or insulated jackets and that's the brand PHD. That's for a cost.

Back to the women's thing, there's certainly good enough in women's coats. My partner owns two longer coats that cost as low as £40 that has had seriously a hard use for a number of years now and are standing up well. If you can get a longer, insulated coat for women for £40 that lasts then I'm not sure why you'll pay £280 for a Didriksons one. If you're a woman that is.

In the last cold spell a neighbour was wearing a Canada goose parka. It looked warm but the guy looked a bit smug in it. He's like that and I reckon he got it for that show off look too.

Fjallraven looks like it took a step up in designs a few years ago to compete more. What I mean is they produced more regular looking items to compete on the larger, more mainstream market. To me that is a worry as most brands doing that with a high rep tend to shift downwards on quality. And I really don't buy the natural products offcuts use like leather zipp puller taks and labels thing. Seems eco marketing to me. Ever the cynic, eh?!
 
The thing about parkas for men is they are almost the only way to get longer coats for less energetic uses like my use situation. Army surplus perhaps but modern puffer jackets for men are shorter length.

For women less of an issue. There's many brands from cheap to expensive that offer longer puffer jackets for women, usually fitted because all women want to show off their figure when it's cold and they're walking the dog in the dark, right?

AFAIK there's only one brand that will supply longer puffer or insulated jackets and that's the brand PHD. That's for a cost.

Back to the women's thing, there's certainly good enough in women's coats. My partner owns two longer coats that cost as low as £40 that has had seriously a hard use for a number of years now and are standing up well. If you can get a longer, insulated coat for women for £40 that lasts then I'm not sure why you'll pay £280 for a Didriksons one. If you're a woman that is.

In the last cold spell a neighbour was wearing a Canada goose parka. It looked warm but the guy looked a bit smug in it. He's like that and I reckon he got it for that show off look too.

Fjallraven looks like it took a step up in designs a few years ago to compete more. What I mean is they produced more regular looking items to compete on the larger, more mainstream market. To me that is a worry as most brands doing that with a high rep tend to shift downwards on quality. And I really don't buy the natural products offcuts use like leather zipp puller taks and labels thing. Seems eco marketing to me. Ever the cynic, eh?!
I have a really old mountain equipment lightline down jacket that covers my bum. But it is fairly bulky and a bit fragile.

Duffel coat might be an alternative that is long, warm and not surplus.
 
I'm going to throw something new into the mix, Not necessarily for myself but I'm thinking of those people in our lives that complain < endless mundane white noise on a mans soul gnawing away at his very reason for living .... > about the cold.

As heated jackets are now a thing- are there any good suggestions?
 
I have a really old mountain equipment lightline down jacket that covers my bum. But it is fairly bulky and a bit fragile.

Duffel coat might be an alternative that is long, warm and not surplus.
My ME lightline was when they first brought out the "new" colours of blue with orange details on the logo. Must be 90s. It was a smock and back then it came without a helmet that was an extra purchase and press studded onto the smock. It is bulky and short on me. A little too big on the body but nowhere near long enough. Perhaps the more modern jacket version is longer than the over the head smock version.

OMG! Duffel coats? They were always horrible in my primary school days. They were not waterproof and even not that warm from memory. Wind blew through the opening which was closed with an inadequate toggle closure. Once wet it never dried out all day and smelt funky once wet too. A kids jacket that is best consigned to the fashionistas in cities who every so often bring them back into high fashion IMHO of course.
 
I'm going to throw something new into the mix, Not necessarily for myself but I'm thinking of those people in our lives that complain < endless mundane white noise on a mans soul gnawing away at his very reason for living .... > about the cold.

As heated jackets are now a thing- are there any good suggestions?
Not sure what the gnawing away at soul comment is about but ski jackets come in heated versions. Usually designed for skiing and I am not sure skiing jackets make a good one for non-skiing activities. Mine is not heated but I find it too skiing focussed. For example mine has sections that have no insulation so you do not overheat when skiing I guess. Also mine is too short. It is kind of like an inch or two too short for me (I am 196cm tall which might be the reason it is too short for me). By short I meant if it was raining when wearing it the water would run off onto my groin not my thigh. Unfortunately the UK winter use also needs good rain cover. IT is afterall meant to be a jacket to wear without waterproof trousers.

I am thinking I might wear it out a bit next cold spell at night to see what it is like. Good information when considering needs for parka option. I think last year on a cold night's dog walk I felt cold. Thinking on that it might have been that weird non insulation strip around the arms.
 
Just pick something and buy it.
If you are struggling with "outdoor" brands, try the more general stuff, like:

or

The endless analysis paralysis isn't good for you. Its not good mentally and does nothing substantive to keep you warm or dry ;). At this rate, you will be too old to cycle or commute to work before you find one you think is perfect.

I have about 14 assorted jackets, coats and smocks, collected over about 30 years. None are perfect, but I can still enjoy wearing each one at some point or other.
 
Just pick something and buy it....


....The endless analysis paralysis isn't good for you. Its not good mentally and does nothing substantive to keep you warm or dry ;). At this rate, you will be too old to cycle or commute to work before you find one you think is perfect.
Very true. "Spoilt for choice".

Unless it requires almost bankrupting yourself, buying a coat is not a life-changing decision.

Too many people become obsessed with looking at reviews of everything nowadays.

If required, just pick a coat or two that suit your different needs.
 
I did purchase a Carinthia jacket a while back .

Was anticipating it coming and being the dogs favourite tongue toy.

Read all the reviews.
I could justify the big spend ( at least for me ) - " Buy once - Cry Once " etc.


When it arrived and I was trying it on and mincing around in it , I had an unpleasant realization.

It was too big ( even for me ) and by that I mean not sizing just the volume of it .
It was too 'crisp packet' - just not quiet enough to suit my apex predator ( :) ) sashaying bimble.
It was simply overkill.

And it looked like a Minecraft outfit. But that maybe my fault.


I guess the point is don't fixate. Yes do some research but its just a jacket.
 
Just pick something and buy it.
If you are struggling with "outdoor" brands, try the more general stuff, like:

or

The endless analysis paralysis isn't good for you. Its not good mentally and does nothing substantive to keep you warm or dry ;). At this rate, you will be too old to cycle or commute to work before you find one you think is perfect.

I have about 14 assorted jackets, coats and smocks, collected over about 30 years. None are perfect, but I can still enjoy wearing each one at some point or other.
Not analysis paralysis but I am too tight to spend the money on what I want / have chosen. :shameful:

I am still hoping against hope that there is a coat as well designed and equivalent to a Fjallraven parka but costing as little as possible (sub £100 if possible). Even the surplus look doesn't work my stinginess.

I think I must just suck it up and spend money on what I have chosen!! ;)

PS I worked out the cost of a sewing machine, fabric and materials means I would not beat the cost of a Didriksons parka. :rolleyes:
 
Not analysis paralysis….

Denial.

Wanting something. Making countless posts on multiple threads over multiple years about wanting something, but not buying it. Not because you can’t afford one (at worst, save for three years, done) but because you want to optimise value for money, performance, looks, length, etc and are still analysing (searching) the market for a unicorn alternative. This is practically a classic case study example ;)

I know I have and do suffer from this, but the first step to overcoming it….and in your case moving forward to warmer and drier commuting, is recognising that it is a problem. Think of all you could have done with the time you have spent thinking about and writing about choosing a winter coat :biggrin2:

:grouphug:
 
I bought a genuine US navy peacoat like this.Just for cold winter conditions. Have even worn it hiking on lowland areas and not sweated even though it is heavy wool-but again in winter. Have also used it in winter downpours around town of a couple of hours-it got wet but I was still warm. Surprisingly versatile but only for the real cold -for mem at least
 

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE