I have quite a variety of different pairs of gloves, depending on the work and the weather.
I have long skinny fingers, doesn't take much for my hands to feel cold.
Top brand for variety here is Watson. I always pick leather outers as they
don't seem to be slippery against other objects (car keys/door handles, shovel & axe handles/etc).
Any sort of a cloth liner, fuzzy or not, is better than bare leather for warmth for me.
Garden/yard gloves are cheap, 3 pairs for $10.00 and more durable than I expected.
Thick and fuzzy inside for driving in cold WX (like down to -20C)
Heavily insulated for outdoor winter work (snowmobile gloves, excellent dexterity, too)
Thick cloth lining for wood working and wood carving = warmth as well as soaking up vibration.
Because I have many pairs for different things, I'm finding that they all last a long time without wearing out like fingetip holes, etc.