daved said:
They look nice and small and the design looks like it would be easier to get the sparks where you need them without scattering the tinder (as I clumsily manage with a firesteel).
I think I remember seeing an old thread saying that these worked OK with the supplied tinder but not much use with anything else.
Could anyone who has used one comment on this please? Are they any good with natural tinders?
I'm by no means an expert, but perhaps your technique with the tinder and firesteel may need a little tweaking. If I may, I'll share a bit of how I do it. Not that it's the best way, but it works well enough for me.
I use the awl of my SAK as striker when using a ferro rod like the hotspark or firesteel. I hold the tinder to the awl so that it drapes over the blade, away from the firesteel. I tuck the ferro rod under the tinder and then holding the tinder and awl stationary, I draw the ferro rod back. The resulting sparks are thrown directly into the tinder, which usually ignites on first try. I hold the tinder close enough to the prepared makings for the fire, so that I can drop it and slide the burning tinder into possition using the blade of the SAK or a stick. If small tinder shavings are involved, I bundle them inside of cotton or similar and the fluff ignites the shavings.
As for the spark-lite being adequate enough to ignite the more natural forms of tinder, it depends on how the bundle is prepared as to whether it will work. Placing those flammable materials like birch bark, that would be difficult to ignite with the spark-lite in their whole form, into a bundle that has a tinder fluff at it's heart, then the birch bark and then something to hold it all together like dried moss, etc., would enable the sparking tool to work well, by igniting the fluff and folding everything loosely onto itself and gently blowing the bundle to get it to flame.