point taken, I do however trust more a medical doctor who's whole medical career has been dedicated to wilderness medicine vs an EMT_W.... while not understating the training EMT_W's receive...their whole agenda is to get them to the hospital as quickly as possible. The books I suggested are for those instances where a hospital and professional care is not in the cards. Either way, they are worth a look, and could help you save a life one day. It is always easier when you have O2, helicopters, doctors and nursing staff on call prepped and ready to receive a patient vs lets say a bad fall while climbing, you're miles from anyone and you're watching someone die in front of you. while first aid will help, would you rather know this info and not need to use it, or need to use it and not know how to help? Take it in the spirit in which it was given. I'm not here to make waves or step on toes, but if I didn't have the medical training I have, and someone knew of a book I could read that would be beneficial to me, I would like them to share it..... I can make up my own mind later on. I could consult with my doctor on the validity of treatment suggested etc. Hope this helps.