Wow Monbiot is a pretentious idiot isn't he?
Some of his writing I have little interest in, but I can't disagree with him in any way when it comes to his views on agriculture and food production. I could have told him half of what he says 20 years ago.....
I fundamentally disagree with most of what he is saying. We have no need of manure? Absolute rubbish. Soil erosion in the Fens is measured in tonnes, per acre, per year precisely because there isn't enough manure and other organic matter worked back into the soil. So much so that it is now almost sand and minerals with minimal humus and can only raise a crop through over irrigation and the addition of massive quantities of mineral fertilizers. To suggest we need to exaggerate that effect is insane.
Different areas, different issues. I'm not familiar with the farming practises on the Fens. The warmer parts of Wales, the farmers are limited in the amount of manure that goes on the land. They have a surplus. I know of one local farm to me, who hauls two tanker loads of manure from Carmarthenshire to Brecon, every day. It goes in a bio digester, to produce "clean" energy.
This manure is the by product of milk production, it's slurry.
I don't think my example is in any way unusual.
I live, and was raised, in the middle of an area where so much of what he writes about agriculture is something that I see every day. I just can't disagree with the bloke.
Nope, still dont buy it. His giveaway is "ethical if we ate less meat". There is nothing unethical about eating meat that is organic and high welfare. There is a very great deal wrong with eating vegetables farmed so intensively that the fields are monoculture desserts with all insect and higher life forms extinguished. If the man thinks animals are not killed in vegetable farming he is not just an idiot, but a dangerous idiot. How does he propose to return organic matter to all these veg fields? Human manure spreading?
Its not a policy its an absurd agenda that is transparently unworkable.
so can you shoot greys and are they "safe" to eat??? I know they're a delicacy in the southern states of USA but does anyone eat them here? (I imagine theyd be like mini rabbit)