Advice required...

[Jon G]

Hello wise folk.
I really need some help deciding which of these packs would serve me best. I've read the many reviews on here, and am still struggeling to decide.
I realise there are many variables to consider; but I'm looking for a well built pack for weekends away in the woods and longer walking holidays.
Out of these two, which would you purchase?
Thanks in advance, Jonathan.

Berghaus Vulcan Bergen

Tasmanian Tiger Range Pack

 

[santaman2000]

Process of elimination prices the TT waaaay out of my range.

 

[Squidders]

Out of those two... Karrimor Sabre 75

 

[maddave]

The Vulcan has been military battle proven for over 30 years in its various guises.. No pretty pictures or flowery sales hype. Just thousands of serving squaddies always choosing it as the pack of choice... Is it pretty no, does it do the job, yes and then some.... Will you break it, as a civilian VERY doubtful. It's not the lightest of packs but it should outlast you. I sold my vulcan in the late 90's after many years HARD use in the service. It had been jumped on, thrown out of helicopters, shot (4 rounds and I wasn't wearing it at the time) used as a makeshift stretcher seat to casivac a comrade, it has been covered in mud, snot, blood and other unmentionables and came through it all. Am I gutted?? So much so that I'm buying a new one this week. If you go for one make sure you get the right size

Size 2 - 5'3'' to 5'8''.
Size 3 - 5'9'' to 5'11''.
Size 4 - 6' to 6'6''.

 

[Dave]

Out of those two... Karrimor Sabre 75

Make sure its the right back length though.

As Mad Dave says, Vulcan.

 

[Jon G]

Gentlemen, Your advise is much appreciated! I think I will end up purchasing the Vulcan. Most reviews mention the no frills, robust design, and thats exactly what I want.
Thanks again, Jonathan.