I like waxed cotton, but then I rarely now need to wear one when working hard.
For dawdling, for Autumn, early Spring and Winter wanders, they are brilliant. Sitting around a fire, for a walk on a windy day, or in and out of the car on a dreich one, they're bombproof.
For slaving away and rushing around or carrying heavy packs even my wool lined instead of chilly when wet cotton gets damp inside. Dries out fairly quickly however, especially if you do the whole ventilation at the hem and neck thing
John, if you're making your own, use some of that brilliant Welsh flannel to line it and give the cotton stuff a bodyswerve. It really is worth the effort
I have a stash of the heavyweight brass zips.....give me a measurement and a preferred colour and I'll have a looksee
M