Spearfishing... or feed yourself for free at the seaside.

  • Hey Guest, Early bird pricing on the Summer Moot (29th July - 10th August) available until April 6th, we'd love you to come. PLEASE CLICK HERE to early bird price and get more information.

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
Hi all well here is the long promised post on spearfishing, not strictly bushcraft but perhaps of interest and could be another string to anyones bow.

Firstly let me state that spearfishing, freediving and the coast in general are all inherantly dangerous, this article intends to provide an overview of the sport i enjoy not instructions, dont attempt anything here without proper instruction/knowledge of the sport its dangers and the sea.
My second note is that this article will deal with Freedive spearfishing, as this is what i do but also as in my view it is the only way to do it whilst keeping things as natural, fair and humane as possible. Some countries UK included allow spearfishing whilst using scuba equipment but many dont. These skills are transferable but in my opinion using scuba defeats the freedom aspect and also swings odds much more in the hunters favor making the taking of game less of a challenge, and in my view less ethical.
Lastly In the UK spearfishing in fresh water is illegal, so dont be tempted no matter how nice those trout look!

What is freediving.....:
Most of you have probally freedivied before whether you know it or not, freediving is often described as a breath and an inch... or more precisely descending beyond an inch of water depth, holding a single breath of air. Another way to look at it is to imagine scuba diving, but without the breathing apparatus.
Freedivers explore the underwater world, gathering game, taking photos or setting records using only a single held breath taken at the surface before each dive. Specialist equipment helps; longer fins, wetsuits, mask and snorkle etc. but it comes down to the ability of the freediver to be comfortable in his/her surroundings, their skill in conserving energy and oxygen, their ability to store/maximise oxygen in their tissues and lungs and their natural ability and practise in performing tasks in a state of 'apnea' (essentially without oxygen/with only the oxygen stored in their bodies).
Most people are capable of freediving to some extent but it takes practise and physical and psycological training to begin to push the boundaries of what humans can endure. To give you some idea the current world record for static breath holding (without swimming/moving) is 9 mins 40 secs.... think about that.. then try holding yours for 30secs... see?!
The current depth records for swimming as deep as possible vary on different disciplines but the most relatable one is constant weight.. where the diver must descend and return safely to the surface under their own power carring the same weight on the ascent as the decent.. all on a single breath of air.. this currently stands at 111meters... straight down, and back up of course!
If anyone is interested in learing more about freediving i suggest watching a movie called 'The Big Blue' or check out AIDA the international freediving association.

What is Spearfishing....?
Spearfishing in this instance refers to the general gathering of game, in or under the water whilst freediving (see above).
In the UK most spearfishing takes place between 0 and 15meters depth, although many may go deeper for more elusive fish and game or just to sight see. I regularly dive to 25-30meters but most of my game gathering is done in the first 15.

What is there to eat....?!
The UK is blessed with some of the worlds most diverse ocean life, and pretty much all of it is edible.. although not all tasty! Most spearfishers concern themselves with gathering the best of whats on offer.. this includes..
- European Sea Bass... the prize UK fish, spooky and elusive but very tasty and much too expensive in the shops!
- Other 'round' fish such as: Grey mullet, Red mullet, Pollock, Sea Bream, Cod, Mackerel, Gar fish... the list goes on take a look at a fishmongers counter and you get the idea!
- Flat fish... Such as Plaice, Turbot and Lemon Sole.
- Rays.. In any number of forms but often better known as Skate.
- Crustaceans.. Lobster (need i say more!?) Crab (Brown or edible, Spider and the small but sweet swimming crab), Crayfish and Longuistines.
- Shellfish.. Scallops, Oysters, Mussels, Whelks and Clams.
Of course there is much more especially for the more adventurous.. Like Conger Eel, Shark, Dogfish, John Dory, Seaweed.. the list is possibly endless!

But its the UK will i see anything?!
True the UK doesn't have the clearest waters, but providing you find a sheltered area or there hasnt been a severe storm for a few days viz is usually quite good, 1m viz is diveable and you can hunt in it, but 3m is about the average, on good days ive seen viz well over 15m.

So how do i get it...?
Well aside from finding someone to show you the ropes, much of this bounty 'could' be found in rock pools and on the shoreline.
However to spearfish in the UK you would need..

- A wetsuit, come in all shapes and sizes but a proper two piece one designed for the job will keep you warm i use a two piece 5mm one and am in the water for up to 8 hours at a time.. the zip up back surfing jobbies wont cut it with that sort of use.
- A speargun.. these can be brought or made and vary from cheap and cheerful to extortionate hand carved monsters, all do pretty much the same job and power a spear (usually INOX Steel) which is attached to the gun or a float by a line (usually monofilament... but about 600lb+ breaking strain).
The guns power the spears using either elastic bands (thick surgical rubber type) or compressed air.
The choices are endless but a good option for UK waters is one of a barrel length around 75cm this gives a good balance of size and power/range. The bigger the gun the higher the power and greater the range. Most fish are shot within 3 meters of the diver.
- A knife.. its an important safety device for cutting lines and dispatching fish.. not so much for fighting sharks!
- Weightbelt and weights. These counter act the bouyancy of the wetsuit
- Surface Float and line.. The floats main function is to make you visible to other sea users.. mainly boats but also can act as a rescue device or for storage. The line is obviously so it doesnt float away from you!
- Fins.. any will do and some people use none but to maximise your dive time and save energy specific freediving ones are best.. these are big (my current ones are over 85" long) and take some getting used too.
As with all sports there are tons of gadgets, gizmos and nice to have items but you can be successful with the above or less.. In warmer climates many dont use a wetsuit, some people use a hand spear instead of a gun I guess its down to personal preference, local laws and skill!

Once you have all your gear and some tuition the next bit is easy you get in the water and go hunting..
Fish like all animals feed in certain places, like certain conditions and habitats and have certain needs, knowing these will enable you to find them. For example, knowing flatfish feed on the changing of the tide and generally on a sandy bottom with weed/rock nearby gives you a guide of where to look.
Fish like Bass are pelagic, meaning they are open water feeders, but they hunt smaller fish, who live near shelter.. rocks, wrecks etc. and hide in shelter themselves when not feeding.
As an easy rule areas with broken bottoms of rock and sand, with plenty of sea weed are usually excellent areas to hunt. Of course all fishermen have their own secret hotspots but we dont divulge them!
Once in a fishy area you have two options swim around the area, both on the surface and near the bottom looking for fish or drop to the bottom and wait hoping to see a fish passing or coming to investigate. Both work, either way when you see your target its a case of aim, shoot and hopefully retrieve your catch.
The benefit of spearfishing is you always see what your shooting at so you can be selective, not shooting at fish you wont use or not taking immature/smaller fish.
Shell fish and Crustaceans:
Gathering these is even easier if spotting them in the first place is often harder, while swimming around keep your eyes open, you may spot that lobster or a field of mussels, dive down pick it up or gather a few and thats dinner sorted.
As a side note Lobsters and Crabs can be nasty things, a small lobster or medium crab is easily capable of breaking a finger (i speak from experience) always pick them up from behind and with fingers as close to where the claws join to the body as you can. (Some will nail you even then!)
Its also illegal to spear crustaceans so even if its a monster lobster intent on biting your arm off dont be tempted as penalties are quite severe.
Im sure i dont have to explain how seaweed could be collected!

So there you have it with a combination of freediving and spearfishing you could have a rather tasty, ecologically sound and free dinner. To give you an idea of whats on offer me and a friend took 8 others camping last year, we supplied enough fish and lobster between us to feed them all and ourselves three meals a day.. mmmm camping with sushi, grilled fish, fresh crab and lobster and shellfish.. not to mention the odd beer. Does it get any better!? Oh yeah, when the tents next door notice you all eating lobster while they have their beans on toast!

Dangers:
This section is important, freediving and spearfishing are dangerous sports, as well as the environmental safety aspect of being in the sea a diver is also at risk of,
- Shallow Water Blackout, the biggest killer of freedivers worldwide. SWB is caused by lack of oxygen. This makes you pass out, obviously under water this is a BIG problem and inevitably leads to drowning. Basically divers are most at risk when surfacing, i wont go into the technical reasons but surfice to say that as a safety measure you should never dive alone and should never push your limits as this greatly increases the chances. Weighting yourself so you will float from -5m is also a good way of increasing your chances of survivial should the worst occur.
- Knots and tangles.. Divers are at risk of becoming trapped underwater by either their own gear or carelessly discarded fishing tackle etc. When holding your breath your time is limited so this can be a problem and is why you should always carry a knife, if you can cut your way free it will save your life. Oh and seaweed will never tangle you up, i almost live in the stuff and its just not capable of it!
- Things that bite, cut or sting.. In the UK there are very few things that could cause you problems, Mako sharks do frequent our shores, and are big enough but ive only ever seen one and he didnt eat me, so thats a rarity. Weever fish are poisonous if stepped on but its much like a bee sting, and you will probally never see it. Other than that remember all fish have defences and should be handled with care, some have spines, or sharp scales, others may have stings. Luckily there is nothing in the UK i know of which is likely to put an end to you so general caution in handling things will save you from the odd cut or scrape.
-Spearguns.. These are dangerous weapons, and as such should be treated like a rifle at all times, never load one or have one loaded out of the water, dont point it at anything or anyone other than fish, know where your spear is going to go should you miss and keep your safety catch on at all times. Spearguns are easily capable of killing and will travel for huge distances if accidentally fired out of the water.

Law:
Currently spearfishing is a slight grey area although this is changing slowly.
The same laws apply to spearfishers as to commercial fishermen as to sizes and species of fish, shellfish and lobsters you may catch. Some areas also have fishing bans due to breeding or local limits, so always check what you can land, where you can catch it and how big it has to be.
Selling speared fish is also illegal, but why would you.. its too fresh and tasty!
Spearguns are currently not under any legislation so no licences are needed although reputable dealers wont sell to under 16's and police will treat is as a dangerous weapon. A good view to take is the same as knife law, if you have it for a valid reason in a valid place no problems, just dont take it to the pub!

Afternote..
Well thats it a brief..ish note on spearfishing in the UK just an overview really, any questions just ask, anyone interested in learning.. just ask.
I find spearfishing not only feeds you, it keeps you healthy, its ecologically sound especially compared to mass fishing/trawling and its great fun!
Should you catch dinner or not you can guarentee you will see something every trip that will stay in your mind forever.. some of my more memorable dives in the UK have included..
Playing fetch with a dolphin
Swimming with seals
Coming face to face with a 4m Mako shark
Swimming with a Basking Shark.. 8m long.
Swimming with a whale and its Calf
and a whole host of memories of underwater landscapes, wierd and wonderful creatures, sights sounds tastes...
Not to mention the friends, atmosphere, and relaxing free feeling it gives you.

Hope you enjoy.
Joe.. aka The Fish.
 

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
Just wanted to say hope this thread is enjoyed, i wanted to write so much more but didnt have time and thought i'd probally loose peoples interest halfway through!
Let me know what you think and for more info try these sites.

www.spearo.co.uk
www.portlandoceaneering.co.uk
www.omerdiving.com
www.underwaterfishing.co.uk
www.aida-international.org

Moderators.. if this thread is in the wrong place feel free to shuffle it round.
Would love to post some pictures but need to be on my home PC, currently stuck at work.

Joe
 

underground

Full Member
May 31, 2005
271
10
47
Sheffield
Wow Joe, thanks! That's a really interesting and inspiring post, and I know what I'll be doing on my UK seaside holiday this summer.
Last year I spent most days snorkelling off Lleyn and wondered at the possibilities- now I know!

A couple of questions - do you wear a mask? I find that the salt water hurts my eyes and I'd feel more comfortable with a mask to help the viz - and what about a snorkel? I found it most pleasurable cruising about the surface looking in and breathing through the snorkel, but can imagine it becoming a hinderance when diving underwater 'proper' so to speak.

Lastly how do you counteract positive buoyancy, by using the right amount of lead? I kind of get that impression from your advice about floating from -5m, does this mean you wear some lead but not so much that the air in your lungs can't take you to surface from that depth?

I was frustrated at my inability to get to the bottom on holiday and assumed that I'd need to learn scuba to do that, but hopefully that's not the case..... thanks again mate.
 

underground

Full Member
May 31, 2005
271
10
47
Sheffield
I have done a bit of Googling and it seems that a lot of my questions are redundant now, but it'd still be interesting to hear views on lead, snorkels etc...
 

ilan

Nomad
Feb 14, 2006
281
2
69
bromley kent uk
I think you will need to wear lead to counteract the positive bouancy of the wet suit this is worn on a quick release belt . yes you will need a mask and snorkel must admit i thought spear fishing was banned in this country and think any one spearing undersized fish would be prosicuted . Having dived of the coast of france where spear fishing is allowed there is little in the way of marine life . indeed saw more fish life in one dive of brighton than ten in france .
 

Scuba Pete

Forager
Nov 3, 2005
212
0
45
Glasgow
Hey,

Thought I would just jump with some info. Wetsuits make you very buoyant. Esp. The thick ones. You would never be able to get underwater without a weight belt.

You need fins, a mask and a snorkel. Without fins you will just flap about and do nothing. The snorkel allows you look under the water without lifting your head to breathe. There is no problem diving down with it in your mouth. You simply blow into it when you reach the surface to clear out the water. You should never be without one.

As for buoyancy, to be properly weighted you don your gear including a lead weight belt. The amount you need is different for everyone. Your size, weight, suit thickness, salt/freshwater etc all determines this. Sometimes you need a lot, I am a big guy and when I wear a 14mm wetsuit I need almost 30 lbs of lead. (That’s wearing my scuba gear as well, but that is neutrally buoyant)

The correct way to determine what you need is to swim out so that cannot touch the bottom. When relaxed with a normal breath of air in your lungs you should float at eye level. (You are in a stood up position). When scuba diving you need to do this so that when you breathe out you sink.

When snorkeling you may find that that much weight will mean that u have to work harder to keep floating at the surface. Normally you can take a little off. You have to adjust it so that you can dive down easily and also float on the surface when you want. It’s a balance.

One other important think to remember is that as you descend your suit will get thinner as the gas bubbles in the rubber compress. This means that you will actually become less buoyant and sink faster.

With fins you can easily swim to the surface even if you have expelled some air. All weight belts have a quick release buckle so that you can drop them at any time. This means that if you get into difficulty you just drop your belt and you will be on the surface in no time at all. There is no danger of bends etc, as you are not breathing compressed air.

All I can say is that if you want to start diving and using a weight belt get proper training. Just contact your local dive shop or club and they will be able to help you. They will even sell you the equipment. It’s not expensive but its worth getting good mark, snorkel and fins that fit you correctly.

If you need anymore info let me know.
 
That is a great post thanks for taking the time , I am a scuba diver mainly and just an observer into the underwater world, however I would like to start to catch things I can eat , I did free diving last year for the first time and found it very tiring I am not the fittest guy on the boat :) we did catch a couple of spider crabs but they seemed a bit to small to eat.
I will do some research into what can be eaten and the size regs for next time i go.
 

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
Ok we are back, in answer to the questions asked...
Yes i do wear a mask, without it its basically impossible to focus underwater. Mask choice is a personal thing some fit some dont but always use one with a soft silicone 'skirt' (the rubber bit that rests on your face) hard stiff ones tend to fit poorly and are darned uncomfortable! A snorkle is also used to as someone mentioned allow you to swim looking below the surface without the need to lift your head up for air, however i'll disagree with one comment, about keeping your snorkle in when you dive. True it is easy to 'clear' by blowing the water out as you reach the surface but on a safety note, should the worst happen and you pass out under water resucitation is difficult with a snorkle in your mouth, your teeth will often clamp to it and it also keeps your mouth open encouraging the possible ingress of water to your lungs. Also on a spearfishing note.. its noisy when it fills with water as you dive and that noise scares Sea Bass! If the snorkle is attached properly and safely its no hinderence.. although in record attempts etc they are not used in an effort to cut down as much drag as possible etc.
As for the lead/weight question..
People in general float, especially in sea water (the salt makes it able to float larger denser objects easier.. not sure how to say that technically but there you go!) Neoprene (wetsuit material) is best looked at as millions of air bubbles held together by rubber.. therefore floats very well! Once in a wetsuit you would find it very difficult to get below the surface without adding some weight to make you less bouyant. Its kind of trial and error but a fair guage is if in your full kit with weight you float upright, when you fully exhale you should sink to about eye level in the water, fully inhale and you should float comfortably with your head above water. As for the boyant from 5m bit its for safety, should you pass out... (and this depth is most likely.. let me know if you need an explanation why.. it will be long!) if you float from 5m you will return to the surface from there even unconcious aiding in your rescue/possibly saving your life. Therefore in my case.. i wear 8kg of lead, i float happily without effort on the surface and after about 5m i dont float up or down just kinda hang.. after 10 i sink.., much as i would was i wearing no gear and diving naked.. this isnt reccommended in the UK!
Spearfishing in the UK is definately legal and a fairly fast growing sport, as for in france your right the Med has been horribly over fished but the north west is excellent diving.
Diving without fins is possible, but yes they make it easier, i can dive without fins to 10 or 12m but to give you an idea of the help they give i can dive to 35+ with them, deepest ever is 46m.
Fins definately help you swim to the surface, especially from depth where you naturally sink so getting upwards motion is even harder. The air in your lungs bit mentioned is obviously a help to being bouyant, diving on one breath though means you wanna save it.. so its never breathed out in a dive except small amounts to equalise the pressure in your ears or mask.. or sometimes to blow bubbles for your own amusement! Serious freedivers do run the risk of the bends but its not something you should worry about unless descending continuously to very deep depths.. (i might start worrying if i was descending past 30m constantly all day)
It is true you need to be fit to do well at the sport but not hugely so... i drink, smoke although im giving up, and eat a lot.. however i do swim an average of 5 miles each day of diving, spending about 6 hours in the water maybe half that working without breathing.. only exercise i do is the diving, and i cycle 5 miles a day... to work and back!
Spider crabs are my favourites.. they are fiddly as the legs and claws are small but can hold a lot of meat and its sweeter that the commonly seen brown crab, try it in pasta with a simple tomato and chilli sauce.. mmmm
 
  • Like
Reactions: underground

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
divetrip001zx9.jpg


Thats the remains of a 10lb bass taken last year at the Eddlestone Lighthouse.

divetrip002uo1.jpg


Thats me and the lads poncing around.. same trip.
 

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
p1010154st0.jpg


Cold January days catch.. The ray could have been a Uk spearfishing record.. however we ate it before we thought to check... it would have been close none the less.

p1010035pa1.jpg


Summer days catch of Bass and lobsters on the South Coast

p1010206zj1.jpg


Nice day picking up lobsters.. makes you mighty popular on the campsite!

mespearek7.jpg


Gotta love it!
 

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
titusandpinchysb7.jpg


The mother of all lobsters.. named Mr Pinchy.. held and gaught by my dive partner, Titus. He came from our secret spot it yields one this size every year without fail....

p1010207dz3.jpg


This is a plaice, weighed in at 6 and a bit lb if i remember.. and a grey mullet at over 10lb

Hope you enjoyed.. offer of taking/teaching any of you is still open any more questions just ask.
Joe
 

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
Yes he was, 16lb if memory serves, he was biggest we have had from that spot but we get one ten pounder+ a year, last year we had two both over ten on the same dive.
Lobster and crab are easy, like you said boil in a covered pot.. 15mins a pound is a good rule of thumb, i usually guess the weight and add an extra 15 for good measure. The meat isn't effected like fish etc. too badly by over cooking. But under cooking is horrible... and slimey!
Then do with it as you will... bit of garlic butter and parsley for the lobster and you wont go far wrong.
Oh and to cook Mr Pinchy we borrowed a tea urn from the local scout group! However we have now got a old oil barrel and an open fire to cope with the situation again!
Glad the post was enjoyed and hope ive encouraged some of you to give it a go.. Off to start on my new project, four matching dive knives for the me and the lads in the photo. As long as they are finished for our annual spearfishing pilgrimage to Looe this year all will be ok!
Joe
 

Nikolai

Tenderfoot
I don't really like spear fishing, nothing personal, but in untrained hands it seems like a really easy way to kill a diver. The only reason I say this, is because my brother is a diver, and some guy (who was a n00b, never used a spear before) with a spear got my brothers mate by accident. Wasn't fatal (as such) but pierced his left lower calf. All i say, is if you dive, be careful of spearfishers, and if your a new-to-the-sport spearfisher, be careful of divers.

Just my 2p
 

Joethefish

Tenderfoot
Dec 8, 2006
64
4
43
Warwick, Midlads UK
Fair comment, as hopefully i mentioned thougherly enough above spearfishing is a sport with risks and spearguns can and have been lethal so should be treated with respect. Its sad that some stupid people can bring reputations on the rest of a sport due to their own silly actions. Shooting being a prime example. Hope your brothers mate is ok, with no permanent damage. Dont let one incident put them off the water for life.. its too nice a place, took me a year to be confident in the wild after getting shot by poachers but cant think how dull life would be without it now. Mind you think i'd rather a .222 any day over a spear, ouch.
Best wishes
Joe
 

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE