Why do people say...

  • Hey Guest, Early bird pricing on the Summer Moot (29th July - 10th August) available until April 6th, we'd love you to come. PLEASE CLICK HERE to early bird price and get more information.

Kim

Nomad
Sep 6, 2004
473
0
50
Birmingham
Why do people say it's too cold to snow...? It's cold in Scotland and it snows there...it certainly snows in Sweden, Iceland...etc etc. Is there absolutely any basis to this statement or did some bloke just make it up one day because he was bored...? :shock:
 

Justin Time

Native
Aug 19, 2003
1,064
2
South Wales
it doesn't sound right does it? I guess it's because the colder the air the less moisture it can hold and therefore the less snow it can produce. Also if I can remember this correctly cold air in the UK often comes from an easterly direction, ie continental europe/russia so it won't have have spent much tiome over sea to pick up moisture. I'm now at the limit of my weather knowledge but some of our bigger snowfalls happen when cold fronts meet warmer moister air coming from the west, ie from the atlantic.

I await correction from more knowledgeable types, with pleasure
 

tenbears10

Native
Oct 31, 2003
1,220
0
xxxx
I have no idea where this comes from. The only thing I can think is that there is a temprature below which it physically doesn't snow by which I mean there is loads of snow on the ground but it won't fall from the sky. Now I have a sneeking suspision that it snows up north when it is very very cold so if there is such a temprature it is a long way down the scale.

So how cold has it been and you've seen it actually snowing?
 
Nov 29, 2004
7,808
22
Scotland
My very brainy sister tells me that there is a temperature window within which snow crystals will form, below which the water falls as hail or lumps of ice. In the Artic or elswhere where it is really cold at ground level, a higher temperature exists within the clouds because the water molecules are banging against each other and thats how snow can fall when its ridiculously cold...

Sounds good, but then she talks to cats so I'd take anything she says with a pinch of salt....
 

jakunen

Native
tenbears10 said:
So how cold has it been and you've seen it actually snowing?

Not me personally but -35 in Siberia (before windchill) and you couldn't see your hand infront of your face.

Personally -15 in northern Michigan having a snowball fight with family. Big soft fluffy flakes that stuck to your eyelashes making dodging snowballs aimed at your groin (little kid height) very erm, 'fun'?...
 

arctic hobo

Native
Oct 7, 2004
1,630
4
37
Devon *sigh*
www.dyrhaug.co.uk
It's true, I have seen it clear as can be at 40 below. You know in the winter when there are those really cold days that are clear? It's high pressure weather system, and there will be no precipitation, rain or snow. In lower pressure you'll get precipitation but it'll be warmer.
 

R-Bowskill

Forager
Sep 16, 2004
195
0
59
Norwich
Clouds hold in the heat, so the less cloud the colder it's likely to get at night, also without clouds there's nothing for the snow to come from. When it's clear and frosty it can't snow cos there's no snowclouds not because it's too cold.

People say 'it's too cold to snow' as an observation of a non causal relationship. The same as birds migrating don't make winter or spring arrive. But have been thought to bring the chance in the weather.
 

Adi007

Bushcrafter (boy, I've got a lot to say!)
Sep 3, 2003
4,080
0
http://www.theweatherprediction.com/habyhints/222/
http://starryskies.com/articles/2002/12/physics-snow.html
http://nsidc.org/snow/faq.html
Is it ever too cold to snow? No, it can snow even at incredibly cold temperatures as long as there is some source of moisture and some way to lift or cool the air. It is true, however, that most heavy snowfalls occur with relatively warm air temperatures near the ground - typically 15°F or warmer since air can hold more water vapor at warmer temperatures.

A better way to phrase it is "in a climate like we have in the UK lowlands, colder air doesn't encourage snowfall".
 

Carcajou Garou

On a new journey
Jun 7, 2004
551
5
Canada
The artic is a desert as far as new precipitation is concerned, Andy is right the closer to 0c the better the chances for snow but it can still blizzard at
-40c mostly snow picked up from past snowfalls and new clouds blown in for good measure.
just a thought
 

arctic hobo

Native
Oct 7, 2004
1,630
4
37
Devon *sigh*
www.dyrhaug.co.uk
Carcajou Garou said:
The artic is a desert as far as new precipitation is concerned, Andy is right the closer to 0c the better the chances for snow but it can still blizzard at
-40c mostly snow picked up from past snowfalls and new clouds blown in for good measure.
just a thought
... don't want to be a smartarse, but you mean the Antarctic. The arctic is basically water for half the year y'see.
 

Carcajou Garou

On a new journey
Jun 7, 2004
551
5
Canada
I stand corrected, "an", but the central northern polar ice cap itself is still frozen all year if I am not mistaken?, it is getting smaller though and it is receeding from the shores for a greater distance and stays "wet" for a longer period of time. Please advise :wave:
just a thought
 

Lurch

Native
Aug 9, 2004
1,879
8
52
Cumberland
www.lakelandbushcraft.co.uk
Just like Adi says.
We don't tend to get snow in Blighty when it's real cold, just the way our climate is - doesn't mean it won't but generally it doesn't.
Has as much scientific basis as 'red sky in the morning..' i.e. some but not absolute.
 

arctic hobo

Native
Oct 7, 2004
1,630
4
37
Devon *sigh*
www.dyrhaug.co.uk
Carcajou Garou said:
I stand corrected, "an", but the central northern polar ice cap itself is still frozen all year if I am not mistaken?, it is getting smaller though and it is receeding from the shores for a greater distance and stays "wet" for a longer period of time. Please advise :wave:
just a thought
Yes, that's it. In summer though you can't be sure - certainly none of the ice you could stand on! And you may find the actual true north pole (there are about 5 or 6 :roll: ) might be water as the pack ice moves. In summer you get leads between the floes that may open in day and freeze at night. Certainly you could not attempt to trek there in summer.
The ice is certainly receding as well - have a listen to this http://www.poletrack.com/files/050221_01.mp3. And it's February!
 

BCUK Shop

We have a a number of knives, T-Shirts and other items for sale.

SHOP HERE