Camp knife

[British Red]

I dunno,

Can I hear some billy goats trotting over the bridge? Aah well

Still a nice knife

Red

 

[ecobandit]

I don't like the shape of the handle, or of the knife. I don't like the ridges on the back of the knife. I don't like the ricasso. I don't like the symetrical sheath so you can't tell which way the blade is.

I like the little spacers in the handle. I like the leather colour and effect. I quite like the handle wood.

Not something I'd ever use, but good for you for doing it. I hope it works well for you, it's always good using gear you make yourself.

its a cracking job mate take no notice of kn**head,all I seem to read from "chips" are negative or provocative comments,he seems a right miserable sod to me!.perhaps the "chips" is a chip on his shoulder?:,but whatever that scarf round his neck looks like soft wrinkly skin to me,hmm now where have I seen skin like that before!!!!!!!!!!!! :twak:

 

[John Fenna]

I dunno,

Can I hear some billy goats trotting over the bridge? Aah well

Still a nice knife

Red

I can see the moon rising......

 

[Bernie Garland]

I think being nice for the sake of it is a poor show. He asked for "Comments good or bad welcome, thanks." There were nice things in it that he did that I liked. And some I didn't. I wasn't harsh or overly critical, I gave my opinion. All feedback helps you work out how something could be improved. If we just tell everyone, "you've done a great job, it's perfect", when it's not, people will just keep at the same level and not try to do better.





SimonM, don't try to cause an argument. You're wrong.

You don't like it you dont like it fair enough, but it cost's nowt to be polite does it had enough squabbles here lately so lets not have anymore eah

Bernie

Bernie

 

[Dougster]

I gave my opinion.

SimonM, don't try to cause an argument. You're wrong.

Opinions are one thing, a list of don't likes is difficult to quantify into constructive criticism.

I have read what you said. I believe it discourteous to list dislikes.

I believe it discourteous to criticise in this manner - but I'm not going to tell you you're wrong.

I'm not going to start another heated argument, I'm not saying you did something wrong. The values I live by led me to the course I took.

 

[British Red]

I can see the moon rising......

Is it a bad moon a rising?

 

[Pignut]

clean and elegent blade shape,

no fuss but well executed handle,

Refreshing sheath style

All in all like it!, it somehow looks like a powerful chopper, yet lite (What is the balance like)

 

[MikeE]

Very neat package, I'd certainly buy one!

 

[SimonM]

Chips, Sorry - I may have been a liitle quick to bite

Lets get back on thread...

Simon

 

[Bernie Garland]

Very neat package, I'd certainly buy one!

Argh thought you wanted one of my folders

Bernie

 

[Peter_t]

i like it, its good to see something which isnt typical of a bushcraft knife.

pete

 

[spiritofold]

its a cracking job mate take no notice of kn**head,all I seem to read from "chips" are negative or provocative comments,he seems a right miserable sod to me!.perhaps the "chips" is a chip on his shoulder?:,but whatever that scarf round his neck looks like soft wrinkly skin to me,hmm now where have I seen skin like that before!!!!!!!!!!!! :twak:

I cant believe the language this person is coming out with
I've not seen a post like that since, well, since i last swore!!

I recommend carbolic soap!

Andy >>>>>-------------------------------<>

BTW, i am joking

 

[widu13]

I like the knife and sheath...a lot, but there again I'm a big knife fan- well done.

 

[Mesquite]

Very nice looking knife Roots. I do like that you've left the forging work on the blade and a good job on the sheath.

As for the negative comments I side with Dougster, constructive criticism can be a useful tool for improvement for anyone making things. Saying 'I don't like' just sounds like a spoilt kid sounding off.

 

[korvin karbon]

nice, very nice.

Well done. Do you have any pics of the making process at all?

well done again

 

[ecobandit]

my apologies to one and all I am partaking of the carbolic as I type!!!!!!!!

 

[John Fenna]

Is it a bad moon a rising?

Beyond Credence realy, all this lunacy

 

[spiritofold]

I reckon its down to all the teachers on here! Cos its half term they all been on the booze!!

 

[Scout]

Ver nice knife mate

Nathan

 

[Bernie Garland]

I reckon its down to all the teachers on here! Cos its half term they all been on the booze!!

You might be right Andy

Bernie